Adult-FanFiction.org : Television / Streaming

Wanting What's Not Yours	By : Natasha4000 Category: M through R > Pretty Little Liars Views: 12882 -:- Recommendations : 0 -:- Currently Reading : 1
Disclaimer: I do not own Pretty Little Liars nor the Characters that are in this story furthermore I do not gain money/profit from me writing this story.

Chapter List
- 11
- 12
- 13
Spencer POV:
I watch Toby as he walks towards his locker and I can't help out notice that he seems to always be distracted about something or someone and I can't help but feel a little Jealousy wash over me. Ever since Emily convinced me that he is an okay guy to be around. I've been developing theses feelings for him. To be fair it is understandable, he is hot!
"Toby!"
Toby turns around at the sound of his name being called.
"Oh, hey Spencer"
"Hey. Hmmm, are you busy or anything"
"Er, yea I am why?"
"No reason, just thought we could hang out or something"
"Oh"
"Well are you busy later on or tomorrow or something?"
"Er, yea I am, I have tutoring sessions with Mrs. Montgomery"
"Oh, OK"
"Well I need to go now. I'll see you around?"
"Yea" Spencer gives a small smile.

Ella's POV:
Ella walks into to The Brew.

"Hi is there anything I can get you"

Ella turns around to see a 6 foot tall male with light brown hair and dark brown eyes to match.

"Hmm. No, I'm just wait for one of my students to arrive. You know a tutor lesson"

"Oh right well would do you want anything while you wait?"

"Er, yes could I have a decaf"

"...Here this is on the house"

"Thank you. May I ask why"

"No reason"

"OK. Well thank you"

"Don't mention it. I'm Zack by the way" Zack says giving a flirtatious smile, reaching his hand out in order to shake hers
"Ella" Ella states lightly grasping onto his hand, returning a smile.

"So, Emily works here right?"

"Yea she does. Do you know her or"

"She's one of my student's as well as one of daughters best friends"

"I see. Well she's a sweet girl... She doesn't work today"

Not as sweet as you think. We'll not the way she used to be.

Ella nods in response.

"Are you sure you don't want anything. These have just come out" Zack gestures the fresh pastries.

Ella smiles "I'm sure"
"Mrs. Montgomery"

Ella turns around the owner of the voice.

"Toby"

"You ready to help me study?"

Ella nods before turning back to Zack.

"Thanks again. For this" Ella gestures the decaf.

"My plesure" Zack once again gives Ella a flirtatious smile.

Toby and Ella make the way into a table in the far corner.

"You seem to forget you have a husband"

"Excuse me"

"You flirting with that guy over there"

"I don't know what your talking about Toby. If anyone has forgotten that I have a husband it would be you"

"Look Ella lets not do this here"

"Why not Toby. You did say you want to have me in public, that you want to be able to touch me in public so what's the difference now!"

"Ella I know you angry"

"Angry" Ella laughs

Toby reaches under the table to grasp hold of Ella's thigh causing her to flinch away from his wondering hand. Ella gets up to make her way into the her way into the ladies room. Which Toby got up to follow her.

Entering the toilet Ella turned around to face Toby.

"I'm sure this is the ladies bathroom Toby"

Toby doesn't answer however he goes to check every stal to ensure no one was inside which there wasn't. Toby then begins to walk towards Ella, however she take a few steps further away from him.

"No Toby!"

I'm sick and tired of being submissive to him. I'm sick and tired of being his little pawn in his game he can play with.

"Ella please"

"I said no Toby. I'm not doing this anymore. I won't"

Toby continues to make his way towards Ella until he has almost backed her up into a wall.
I look at the door and I see a potential escape route from this, from everything. It may not make sense but it does at this very moment. I've told him I want this to end. That this has to stop now all I have to do is leave before he persuades me other ways. Before he makes me feel that it's OK to have sick feelings for him, to want him to touch me and for him to allow Emily to touch me. So I run, I run towards the door to escape. However I then I feel his arms rap around my waist and I feel like my chance has gone, any form of escape gone.
Ella struggles against Toby and her breath becomes short. Tears begin to run down her face furiously.

"Ella I need you to calm down. I need you to breath for me can you do that. Come on breath with me. In and out... Yea that's it"

Ella's breathing begins to gradually returned to normal. Toby kisses Ella's neck causes her breath to quicken once again. So Toby turns her around to face him pulling her body towards his. Ella presses her face into Toby's neck.

"I hate you" Ella Whispers into his neck causing Toby's body to stiffen.

"No you don't"

"I do. I hate you so much. You've ruined my life"

"I didn't Ella. Byron did"

"NO! You did. You came and you made me the way I am. You made Emily do what she did to me. You did that not Byron!"

"Ella-"

"Why Toby? Why did you have to push her to do what she did. Answer me! Why?!"

"Because-"

"Because what"

Toby slightly pushes Ella away from him so that her face was now away from his neck.

"Because Ella I know the look she had in her eyes because I once had that look in my eye Ella. She wanted you so I gave you to her like I wish someone did to me"

"She's my daughters best friend Toby. My daughters best friend" Ella emphasizes the last part.

"I know Ella and that part was very unfortunate"

Ella shakes her head in disapproval.

"Look Ella I had to let her do what she did OK!"

"Why!" Ella pleads.

"Because of the same person who gave me what's necessary to destroy your marriage. They enable her to be apart of our deal. There was nothing I could have done about that!"
"But you encourage her! She would have stopped but you encouraged her"

"Look Ella It was either I let her do what she did or A lets all your secrets slip. Me allowing Emily to do what she did allowed me to still have control over the situation you're in right now! Plus If I didn't do what I did she would have told someone"

"I don't care Toby! You involved her in all of this. And who the hell is this A person!"

"I can't tell you that because I don't know who it is myself. I won't see you go down for this Ella. Don't you understand that I care about you"

"You know what Toby I don't. I rather have to deal with a cheating husband, daughter who is dating her teacher and a prison sentence than have to deal with this. Than have to do what I do with you"

Toby nods. I see the hurt flash over his eyes and I feel a sense of guilt was over me for a split second to then be replaced with anger.

"We should go back out before someone comes in or your new boyfriend Zack realizes you're gone" Toby says the last part with resentment.
Ella doesn't respond and just follows him back to their table.

"I Think that's enough tutoring Mrs. Montgomery. Thank you"

"I haven't even taught you anything Toby"

Toby doesn't answer. However begins to pack his things up.

"Thank you Mrs. Montgomery" With that Toby began to leave The Brew.

Ella sighs running her hands frustratedly through her locks and begins to make her way out of The Brew.

"Ella. It was Ella right"

"Yea it was"

"So are you leaving now?"

"Yea I guess"

"Will I see you anytime soon?"

"I'm sure you will Zack"

Zack smiles and nods in response.
Ella walks out of The Brew and begins to make her way to her car.

"I see you still seem to need to be reminded that you're married"

Ella jumps in surprise.

"Do you always have to do that!"

"I like to see you jump"
Ok now I'm definitely sure there is something wrong with him.

"Toby look. I really don't what to do this right now"

"Do what Ella, I'm not doing anything wrong" Toby begins to back Ella onto her car leaving her with her body in between her car and himself, leaving no room for escape.

"Ella. I just thought I should come and tell you, I never aimed to hurt you. Not ever"

"If that was true then you wouldn't have let Emily do what she did! Why would you have even started everything up to begin with"

Toby ignores this comment. Moving his hand to the back Ella's neck before leaning in to kiss her however she began to turn her face away from him.

"Ella don't make this harder than it already has become for you"

Toby leans in again and Ella doesn't refuse him a second time, responding to his kiss.

"I love and care for you Ella. So I'm going to be reluctant to let you go. To let anyone try take you away away from me. Now let me remind you, you are mine Ella and mine only to do as I please with, just because I let you get away with your little temper tantrums doesn't change this. So just remember that the next time you talk to you little guy friend"
With that Toby leaves Ella and begins to walk down the road into the darkness, no longer at view to Ella's eyes.

A week later
Spencer's POV:
I've finally got Toby to give me the time of the day. We are standing next to my locker and he has finally decided to hangout with me today, to just go to my house and chill instead of blowing me off like last week for some tutor lesson. Well I doubt will will just be chilling out but you know.
I see Mrs. Montgomery walk past us and walk into her class. I see Toby's eyes run over her body and not in a way a student should be looking at there teacher. He is basically striping her cloths off with his eyes. What the hell!
"Actually, you know what Spencer, I just realized I can't come over to your house today"
"What! Why? You just said you could"
"I know, but I just remembered I'm busy"
It's funny how he is now busy since Mrs. Montgomery has walked passed. Something is up and I want to know what.
"I'll see you tomorrow or something"
"Yea whatever"
"See you around, oh and tell Emily I should be seeing her very soon"
Funny how he can hang out with everyone but me. Something is up with him and I am determined to find out what it is!
Ella's POV:
I sigh with relief as for the first time since the masquerade ball and Emily's little stunt she pulled in my own home! That I invited her into! In my own room! I have been able to be in the same class as both her and Toby without having a panic attack or mental break down either at the beginning of the class or at the end. So I was actually able to teach my students sufficiently well today and I feel a sense of joy run through me until I heard the ring of the bell to signalising that it was the end of the lesson. The end of the day and I feel my joy quickly begin to die out. I just pray that Toby or Emily leave me to go home so that I can at least just pretend that none of this is happening that this is just all a bad dream, a nightmare I will one day wake up from. Until the next time they decide they want to take advantage of me. However I'm not so lucky, I see Toby from the corner of my eye signal me to wait behind and not leave when everyone had left the class. I sigh once again because I really don't want to deal with this right now. I don't want to have to think that I am basically exploiting my body to one of my students, to someone I used to babysit frequently. I watch as Toby instructs Emily to leave the room with him and I feel a sense of confusion wash over me. Why would have he told me to stay here if he was going to leave?
"Mum. Mum... Mum!"
"Huh. What?" Ella reply's being pull out of her inner thoughts.
"Yes Aria?"
"I was just wondering if I could get a ride home"
"Hmm. Sorry Aria, I can't unless you're willing to wait around until I finish the essay papers I recently got"
Aria looks at her mother sceptically. "You didn't give any essays out mum"
Ella goes to answer Aria but closes her mouth. Repeating the action several times before finally answering. "Well- You see-"
"Mum. Why are you lying to me. Is there something you not telling me, not telling dad?"
"Of course not. It's just that-"
Toby walks back into the classroom.
"You mum's tutoring me, I just ask her not to tell anyone because I was embarrassed"
Aria turns to face Toby. "But why would you be embarrassed?"
"To be honest I don't know. Look Aria, don't blame your mum for lying to you, I made her promise not to tell anyone I know it sounds stupid but I just didn't want anyone to know. But since you know now don't be angry at your mum for lying to you, for coming home late. She just being a good teacher helping out a student. Oh and Aria would you mind not telling anyone please, you no I am supposed to be an the guy who 'doesn't give a damn about school' now I don't really want to mess up my rep" Toby gives a small laugh.
Aria nods. "I'll just get a ride with Spencer. Again"
"I'm sorry Aria"
I watch Aria leave and I can't help but feel guilty for having to lie to her again but I'm only doing this to protect her. To be fair I would have to be doing this if it wasn't for her
"Where's Emily?"
"We had a little talk. She won't be bothering you for sometime"
(The Talk that happened outside with Emily and Toby:
Toby guides Emily outside of Ella's classroom and begins to walk Emily towards her car before stopping to a halt.
"So what did you want to talk about Toby?"
"It's about Ella" This brought a smirk to Emily's face.
"What about Ella?"
"You have to lay off her for a bit"
"What. Why? I did what you told me to do, I was dominate with her!"
"And I don't doubt you weren't. It's just she's not ready for you just yet Em's, she is having a break down and if we let her break down get any worse than it already has then we could both lose her. Is that what you want?"
"Of course not!"
"Then listen to my advice and just give her some time. I'll call you when I think she is ready for you OK. I need to make her more submissive. Ever since you have been with her, the shock of you taking her the way you did has reduce her submissiveness to me and we can't have that if we both want to have her. Can we now?"
Emily begins to pout and shakes her head in refusal.
"That's what I thought to" Toby opens Emily's car door for her.
"I'll see you later Em's"
"Yea I guess" Emily enters her car and Toby watches as he car begins to leave the school premises).
Ella nods gratefully in response. "Thank you Toby for at least understanding that I can't do what you I do with you with her"
"Ella just because I said she won't be bothering you for sometime doesn't mean that she will never touch you again. It just means it won't be so soon nor so frequent. As I like to have you to myself. You are mine after all. Plus I need you to fandom the fact that she will be touching you so that you don't have anymore nervous breakdowns"
"Why are you doing this Toby. She is-"
"I know" Toby begins tiredly. "Your daughters best friend. I have heard you say this several times Ella. You saying it again will not change my mind! She will be apart of our deal whether you like it or not. Whether you accept it or not, you are mine Ella and mine to do as I please with. You know It's funny you don't seem to mind that when I'm fucking you!"
"Toby! Please. Lower your voice!" Toby rolls his eyes at this.
I really don't need anyone to overhear this conversation I'm in enough crap as it is right now. I already have Toby black mailing me because he knows practically all my secret, my friends and family hold. I don't need to add someone else to this sick equation.
"Well it's true. Is it not?"
Ella's cheeks begin to redden in embarrassment. Ella uses her hair to shield her face away from him in embarrassment and denial.
"Well!" Toby directs Ella's face towards him so that she was looking directly into his eyes.
"Answer me! Is it true?"
"Yes"
"Yes what"
"Yes it's true"
"What's true Ella, I want to hear you say it"
"I accept that I'm yours when..." Ella begins to look away from Toby
Toby forcefully redirects Ella face so she was once again looking at him "When what?"
"W-When your fucking me"
Toby smiles "Now was that so hard?"
"Well-"
"Sorry what was that Ella. You know you have to speak up if you have something to say. I can't you know hear you when you mumble"
Toby looks at Ella annoyed "Ella grab your coat and bag and bring it with you were leaving"
"Where are we going?"
"You will find out when we get to the place where going to"
"Toby you know I can't be seen with you outside of school unless you have books with you and It is somewhere that looks study friendly"
"Where we're going is outside of Rosewood so you don't have to worry about that. You will drive in your car to prevent any suspicion if anyone does see us leave the building together and you will just follow my car. Is that clear?"
"Yes"
"Good"
Toby and Ella enter a fine restaurant which is light up with candles and chandelier lights. The room was filled with cream, brown and white colours.
Toby walks towards the waiter and whisper something into his ear before returning back to Ella's side.
"Your table is this way Mr and Mrs. Cavanaugh"
Ella's body freeze's in shock at this.
Did he just say what I think he did! He doesn't even look old enough to be my husband! This is just sick and wrong! I feel Toby's hand wrap around my arm to guide me to the table which seems to be in a separate room away from everyone else at the far end of the restaurant. I feel his hand run down my back causing me to shiver before stopping at my lower back encouraging me to sit down. I sit down and he sits opposite me and look at him questioningly. Why are we here?
"Toby. Why are we here?"
"I wanted to take you out Ella, is that so wrong?"
Ella ignores his question.
"You know, I don't get you"
"What do you mean?"
"It's just you can be so sweet and make me forget about our deal. Treat me with so much respect and kindness a one day and treat me like you truly 'love me' as you so claim, but on other days you treat me like your own personal sex slave! I just don't get what you truly want from me. What your aim with me is or what you intend to accomplish from this agreement. This deal"
"I just want to have you to myself Ella. Just for a bit. I want to be able to treat you as I would if you where truly officially mine. If you where truly married to me instead of Byron.
"Why?!"
"Because your an amazing person Ella"
I can't help but smile at this despite myself.
"So if we where married you would treat me like your sex slave?"
Toby ignores Ella's question and Ella sighs frustratedly in response.
"You don't actually expect this thing between us to last forever"
"Of course I don't expect this 'thing' to last forever, but i'm going to keep this going as long as possible because I'm not ready to let you go right now"
I can't help but just think will he ever be willing to let me go or will I have to fight him to free myself of him. Will I want to fight him? Will I even want to be free of him?
"Toby. Why did that waiter call me Mrs. Cavanaugh?"
"Because I asked him to"
"Why?! I am Mrs. Montgomery and I will always remain that Toby, you must understand that. I will never and I mean never be Mrs. Cavanaugh"
I don't know why I snap but I just do. It's like him telling the waiter that is a sign that this is forever, that I will never be able to go on a day without feeling the guilt of lying and cheating on my husband. Begin exactly like him, a cheat. So I just feel the need to emphasize that I'm married to Byron to at least give my husband some sort of dignity that he is unaware of.
Just then the waiter walks in.
"Is there anything that you two would like?"
I look at Toby and I see the anger flash in his eye's and I feel the emotion of fear run through me. Maybe I should have kept that to myself.
"Would you bring a bottle of red wine and two glasses please"
Red wine. He wants us to drink red wine!
"Of course" The waiter begins to leave to get the order.
Toby begins to move his chair towards Ella so that he was now sitting next her.
"Toby-"
"Don't. Now I brought you here Ella so you could forget about are deal. So I could give you the time I thought you needed but you always seem to overstep your boundaries. Now I'm going to have to put you back in your place Ella. You need to remember that I hold all the cards here Ella not you! I am the one who has stop Emily from coming on to you and I can easily make it begin again by the click of my fingers. I am the one who decided to make this deal with you and I could easily end it. I control this Ella not you"
Toby reaches up and brings to hand to the side of Ella's face to direct it so that she was directly looking at him.
"Now Ella the more you fight me the harder It will get. You will only further piss me off. Now the next time you do not follow an order I give you or you decide to forget your place in are deal Ella. So will I. It will only enable all your secrets to go free, there only safe because of me. Now it's your choice Ella"
Right now I will do anything to protect my family so I lean in to kiss him and he deepens the kiss threading his hands into the roots of my hair, running his tongue along my bottom lip asking for entrance which I willingly grant. I feel his hand slowly and sensually run down the side of my body before going between my legs. He begins to undo the button to my jeans and I moan in protest. We can't do this, not here. Thankfully the waiter walks back in with the glasses and the bottle of wine causing Toby to slowly pull away from me.
The waiter opens the bottle of red wine and pours a generous amount into both glasses.
"Is there anything else you would like"
"No come back in the next 20 mins, then we will be ready to order are main meal"
"OK Sir"
Once again the waiter leaves and Toby begins to place wet kisses on Ella's exposed neck before returning his hand back Ella's jeans to unbutton them. Toby slips his hands into Ella's jeans and begins to rub her covered sex causing her to bit her lip to conceal her moans. He continues his ministrations until he could feel her juices begin to soke her painties. Toby then brought his lips back to Ella's lips, biting and sucking her bottom lip into his mouth causing her to groan before pulling her painties to the side and plunging two fingers into her. causing her to moan his name against his lips. Toby keeps a steady pace.
The sound of Ella's phone brings Toby's ministrations to a halt. Ella looks to her phone then to Toby with pleading eyes asking him to stop.
Toby smirks "Pick it up"
"Toby please" barely manages to get out.
"Pick. It. Up" Ella does as she's told.
"Hey honey. Where are you?"
Toby forces another finger inside Ella quickening his pace, pumping the three fingers inside her.
"I-I'm tutoring a. Student Byron" Ella began to dig her nails into Toby's thigh to prevent herself from moaning out.
"O.K. Well do you know when your going to be home"
"I-" Toby begin to curl the three fingers hitting the right spot that will take Ella into ethiopia.
Ella throws her head back letting out a low groan. Ella begins to lean against Toby and her breath begins to get labored.
"I don't... I don't Know Byron"
"Ella are you alright?"
"Fine"
"Well you don't sound fine"
"I am. I promise. I-It's probably my phone" Toby smirks at the and whispers in her ear "Damn right you are... Do you want to cum Ella" Toby runs his tongue over Ella's ear causing her to shiver.
I subconsciously nod my head completely forgetting I'm still on the phone and I feel him rub his thumb against my clit sending electric jolts through my body and I almost cry out. Almost. I bit my lip and I completely forget why I even have the phone in my hand until I hear Byron call out my name. Bringing me back to the land of living. Completely consumed by pleasure, pleasure I've only felt with Emily and Toby.
"Ella!"
"I-I- I'm sorry w-what was that" Ella looks at Toby pleadingly again and he just smirks in response quickening his pace again, curling his fingers trusting his them at a hard orgasmic pace.
"Fuck!" Ella mouths.
"I said should I order food then since I don't have time to cook and you will be home late and I doubt you would want to come back home to cook"
"Er ye-yea. B-Byron I h-have to go" with that Ella hangs up the phone without waiting for his response.
"Oh shit. Oh shit Toby please, please don't stop. I'm almost there... Yes. YES!" Just as Ella was about to cum Toby removes his fingers.
"NOOOOO! I was almost there, just a few more- Why, why did you do that?!" Ella asks her voice full of frustration.
Toby brings his wet coated fingers to his mouth sucking off Ella's juices off his fingers "Hmmm, Ella you always taste so delicious"
Toby looks into Ella's dark filled lustful eyes. Ella gets up from her chair and raises her leg around Toby so that she was now sitting on top of him with both legs at his side. She then began to place soft kisses on his neck.
"I will do anything you want Toby if you just let me cum" Ella begins to grind her body against Toby causing him to groan.
What the hell am I saying! What the hell am I doing! Why must my body always over take my mind! Why must I hungry, lust and urge for his touch to the point I no longer do things self consciously. I know this is wrong so why can't I just be happy like a normal person would be that he stopped his ministrations. But no I must be different, I must crave more. To be fuck by him to let him let me cum. For him to make me cum!
Toby's POV:
Toby grabs hold of her hips stopping Ella's thrusts against him.
"Now Ella I want you to remember this that I hold the power. If I want to fuck you I will and I want to stop I will. Now this will be your punishment tonight"
"Toby no please, I'll do anything you want"
Toby smiles. Nice to know I have my submissive Ella back.
"Nope" Toby pushes Ella off him guiding her to sit back down in her own seat.
Toby laughs. Look at her all sexually frustrated.
"I think it's time for our main order now, don't you think Ella?"
I see her pout at this, that I will not be continuing our early activity and it takes every single fiber in my body not to just take her on this table right now and just pour the whole bottle of red wine all over her and lick it off every part of her body. Shit I need to stop thinking about these thoughts its making me harder than I already am.
"Now Ella what have we learnt today?"
"To do as you say and not defy you"
Toby smiles "Very good"
The waiter walks back in the room.
"Are you now ready to take your orders now sir?
"Yes, we definitely are"
- 11
- 12
- 13
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

Wanting What's Not Yours