Adult-FanFiction.org : Television / Streaming

Bad Earps	By : MTL Category: S through Z > Wynonna Earp Views: 6441 -:- Recommendations : 0 -:- Currently Reading : 0
Disclaimer: I do not own Wynonna Earp. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.

Chapter List
- 3
- 4
The last few hours had been quite the rollercoaster ride. Bad Wynonna had been found out and captured by her friends, only for Waverly to convince the Demon to return to her body, confident as always that Wynonna would find a way to save her. Wynonna was terrified by the idea that this time would be different. This time she would fail her precious baby girl, and lose her forever. The only upside was that finding her was easy, thanks to lightning firing around the barn on their family estate, and Wynonna remembering just enough of the Demon's evil thoughts to know what her evil plan was. Which was more than enough to fill her with overwhelming terror which threatened to destroy her. And then, when she reached the barn, she found out it was even worse than she imagined.
"Waverly!" Wynonna screamed, which was probably a bad move strategically given she was running blind into the barn, but she just couldn't help it, "Baby girl, please talk to me!"
"Not another step, Demon!" Nicole threatened, pointing her gun at Wynonna's head.
"Nicole, it's me." Wynonna protested, "The Demon switched our bodies again. You have to believe me."
"That's exactly what you would say if you were the one who was possessed." Nicole pointed out, but she was clearly hesitating, not sure who to believe.
After a brief pause Wynonna pleaded, "Please, I'll do anything."
There was another pause, then Bad Waverly softly ordered, "Tell her Wynonna."
"What?" Nicole frowned in confusion.
Wynonna clearly got it immediately from the look on her face, but Bad Waverly pushed the issue, "Tell Nicole what that Demon made you do to me."
"Wynonna?" Nicole questioned.
"Please, not-." Wynonna began.
"Tell her!" Bad Waverly snapped.
Wynonna whimpered, lowered her head and then softly admitted, "I fucked her."
"WHAT?" Nicole exclaimed, and then after a few long seconds shook her head, "No, no that's not possible."
"But it is." Bad Waverly confessed, unable to hide her delight, causing Nicole to back away from her in horror, "And she didn't just fuck me once. No, she fucked me over, and over, and over again. No... she made love to me. At least, at first. Then, all it took was a little push, and she ravaged me. Just like all my other sister substitutes. And just like them, you were just a little toy to distract me from the fact that I'm in love with my big sister. But I don't have to settle for second best anymore. No, I have Wynonna, and you can't even compare to her. Mmmmmmm yesssssssss, she's so good at fucking me. Tell her Wynonna. Tell her about the things we did."
Yet another pause, this the longest yet, and then with tears streaming down her face Wynonna admitted, "I'm, I'm sorry Nicole."
"No..." Nicole murmured in disbelief, "No, no, no this isn't happening. I'm dreaming. I'm having a nightmare. This can't be real. It can't be."
"But it is." Waverly chuckled evilly, "Tell her Wynonna. Tell her or I'll slit Waverly's pretty little throat!"
With those words Bad Waverly suddenly produced a knife which she held to her own throat, causing Wynonna to panic, "NO! No please, I... I love you! I love Waverly! I'm in love with my sister! Oh God, I can't remember what it was like not to be in love with her. This thing, it's not Waverly, but it pushed us together, made a stew thing we would have never of done otherwise... and I'm so grateful to it for that. I loved every minute of touching her, of being with her. Of loving her. I can't help it. I'm sick, twisted and fucked up, but I love her. I always have. She's... she's the one for me. And I just... love her. And I loved fucking her. Her whimpers, her cries, her moans? I could live off of those sounds. And I don't want to stop. I want her to be mine. Mine, always and forever."
"And I want to be hers." Waverly said with a tinge of sadness, her eyes having returned to their usual colour as she looked Nicole directly in the eye and confessed, without even a knife against her throat anymore, "I'm in love with my sister too. I'm sorry Nicole, but I always have been. The whole time we were dating, every moment we have had, and I spent the whole time wishing it was Wynonna. And I would have never said yes to you, or being with you in any way, if I thought being with Wynonna was an option. And now it is, how could I possibly stay away? How could I possibly choose you over my soulmate? You're nothing to me. You always were."
"Oh God!" Nicole wept, falling to her knees, dropping her gun and beginning to cry in despair into her hands.
Immediately capitalising on the redhead's mistake the Demon fully took over Waverly's body again, close the distance between them and punched her in the face as hard as she possibly could, knocking her out cold. Then Bad Waverly turned to her 'sister' and ordered her to, "Tie this bitch up! I want to make her watch us fuck."
Wynonna whimpered and tried to open her mouth to protest, but she barely got it open when the Demon gave her a look which told her not to waste their time. She couldn't possibly talk her way out of this, the statement was too cruel for that, and they both knew that all Wynonna could really do was whatever she was told, and hope the monster gave her the things she needed to get rid of it once and for all. So Wynonna reluctantly tied Nicole to a support beam, which was very much in the middle of the barn, meaning that she would have the perfect view of whatever was about to happen. Poor Nicole actually started coming round in the process, meaning that Wynonna both had to hurry, and secure her friend.
"Good work, sister." Bad Waverly said mockingly, "Now get over here and give your baby girl a kiss, right in front of the mean cop lady. Oh yeah, I want her to see it when she wakes up."
This time Wynonna didn't hesitate to obey, both because she had accepted that once again she had no choice, and more importantly, she just couldn't resist kissing those oh so inviting lips. Kissing her sister, that was what was being offered to her right now, which was something that Wynonna couldn't ever see herself being able to resist again. So despite the fact that Waverly's eyes were black and she was smirking evilly Wynonna closed the distance between them, pulled the younger girl into her arms and kissed her sister right on the lips. Bad Waverly of course didn't hesitate to kiss back, but thankfully she then gave Waverly back control, so it would really be the two sisters who were kissing when Nicole finally came round.
Which took a surprisingly long time. So long in fact that Wynonna was actually hoping that it would never happen. That the combination of the punch and the shock sent Nicole into a deep sleep, which she wouldn't wake up from for hours. Hell, Nicole would have probably chosen death over what was awaiting her when she opened her eyes. But sure enough, eventually Wynonna heard the soft whimpers and cries which told her the police officer was awake, and very much despairing in every moment of this nightmare come true. Which made this the only time that Wynonna didn't enjoy kissing Waverly. And yet she didn't stop. She just couldn't stop, for Waverly's sake.
"Waverly?" Nicole whimpered in a soft, broken voice.
"I'm sorry Nicole, I'm so sorry." Waverly broke the kiss, turned to her now maybe former girlfriend, and apologized, "It's this monster. It's making us say these things."
"So... you don't mean them?" Nicole questioned softly, although deep down she knew the answer to that already, which was only confirmed when Waverly lowered her head in shame, "Oh God."
"I'm sorry." Waverly whimpered again, "I never wanted to hurt you. I never did. But-"
"I do." Bad Wynonna grinned, her eyes going deep black, revealing the Demon had switched bodies again. Then she made another reveal, "And before I make one of you mine forever, I want to leave a lasting impression on the rest of you, by making Wynonna Earp take her baby sister's ass right in front of her girlfriend. Oh yeah, that's right Nicole, Wynonna is going to take Waverly's anal cherry right in front of you. You know, the thing you must have been begging for, for what, weeks? Months? Ever since, you two got together? Not that I blame you. Mmmmmmmm, no, Waverly Earp has the cutest little bubble butt ever. And tonight? It's mine. Mine, and her sister's. What do you say, Wynonna?"
Momentarily getting control over her own body again Wynonna blushed, but didn't hesitate to reply, "Thank you."
"For what?" Bad Wynonna pushed.
"For..." Wynonna gulped, and with an apologetic look at Officer Haught, "Thank you for letting me have my little sister's anal cherry."
"Oh, how delicious?" Bad Wynonna cackled, before turning her attention to her pray, "Well, what are you waiting for?"
"Thank you." Waverly blushed, but didn't hesitate to reply, "Thank you for letting my big sister have my anal cherry."
"That's cute, but I meant get the strap-on." Bad Wynonna chuckled.
"Oh, right." Waverly blushed, scurrying out of the barn to do as she was told.
Nicole told herself that Waverly had no choice, and she had no idea what she was saying, as she was obviously under the influence of this evil creature. Both of the Earps were, so she wasn't even really mad at Wynonna, for once. However, what she was, was broken. Probably beyond repair. Because when she had come too and found the two Earp sisters kissing right in front of her Nicole had frantically tried to get out of her restraints, but it was no use. She was helpless to try and stop whatever happened next, and she feared whatever it was, would be far worse than any ass fucking. Especially given the way that possessed Wynonna was grinning wickedly at her.
Almost immediately after Waverly left Bad Wynonna turned her attention to her other plaything, kneeling down in front of her and telling the poor bound woman, "You know, you're kind of cute. Mmmmmmmm, I've been having lots of fun making the Earps do unspeakable things to each other, but if you asked nicely, I could be persuaded to let you join in the fun."
"Fuck you." Nicole growled.
"Yeah, that's the idea." Bad Wynonna cackled wickedly, and then let out an affronted sound as Nicole spat on her. She then got closer, staring angrily at the redhead for a few long seconds, before smiling evilly again, "You'll pay for that. I promise. But... later. After all, we wouldn't want you to miss the show, would we?"
Nicole didn't reply, but Waverly came back just then, and trying to divert attention, she announced, "I, I got it."
"Then why isn't it already attached to me?" Bad Wynonna questioned, "And why aren't you already sucking on it, like a good whore?"
"Yes Wynonna, sorry Wynonna." Waverly blushed, and quickly did as she was told.
"And make sure you do a good job. Spit is the only form of lube you're getting." Bad Wynonna warned.
This time, there was no reply, other than Waverly leaning down before her sister, or at least the thing controlling her sister's body, and then holding out the strap-on for the possessed Wynonna to step into, which she did, allowing the younger Earp to pull the harness up the older one's thighs. Waverly then firmly secured the strap-on with well-practiced ease, Nicole vividly remembering Waverly doing this for her. In fact, that might've been one of their strap-ons. Either way, it wasn't long before she was spitting onto the shaft, and then rubbing in the saliva with her hand. Bad Wynonna made it clear that wasn't enough for her, but before she had to say anything, she got exactly what she wanted. Namely, Waverly Earp sucking Wynonna Earp's strap-on.
"Oooooooooooh yessssssssssss, that's it baby girl, suck big sister's cock! Mmmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhhhh, suck that big fucking dick, and get it nice and ready for your virgin ass." Bad Wynonna gleefully encouraged, before giving control back to the host, who was more bashful, but continued like a good girl, "Oh God Waves, that's it, suck it. Suck my fucking cock! Oh fuck! Oh my God, my kid sister is sucking my cock! Oh fuck! Oh Wav, mmmmmmmmm, ohhhhhhhhhhhhhh fuckkkkkkkkkkk, you're such a good little cock sucker. Oh yes, take it deep! Take it all, oooooooooohhhhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssss, all the way down your throat! Ah fuck!"
While Nicole had never really been that into receiving a BJ, for obvious reasons, it was truly heart-breaking watching Waverly give one to someone else. Maybe especially her own sister. And she wasn't acting hesitant and disgusted like she should be. No, Waverly was really, really getting into this. More than she had with just about anything with Nicole, suggesting that she really meant the cruel words she had said. And maybe Wynonna continued to mean them, as while it could be another trick, Nicole was fairly certain that Wynonna had control over her mouth again, and was using it to torture Nicole in a less playful way than before. In a way which made her heart feel like it was being literally tortured.
Yet somehow, even through that torture, a small part of Nicole enjoyed it, simply because Waverly Earp look good, doing just about anything, including this. Oh God, and whether it was the Demon or Wynonna, either way the other brunette ended up turning sideways so that Nicole could have the best possible look at Waverly's lips sliding up and down that shaft, eventually pushing it all the way down her throat, just like she'd been only to happy too. And this was just a warm-up for something even more perverted. Something which Nicole would have to watch, and she suspected that just like this, as much as she tried, she just wouldn't be able to tear her eyes away from it.
"That'll do." Bad Wynonna purred, briefly taking back control to gleefully order, "Mmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhh, Waverly Earp just did a great job of proving herself a nasty little cock sucker. Mmmmmmmm, and now, she's going to prove herself to be a nasty little anal whore. Oh yeah, bend over, baby girl. Mmmmmmmm, fuck yeah, bend over and give big sister your virgin butt."
Wynonna got back control right after that, and she wanted to tell Waverly that she didn't have too, but then her baby sister pulled her mouth away from the strap-on, and the two siblings exchanged a look. It was the kind of look, which set a million things at once, including it was okay, and even that Waverly wanted to do this. Then, Waverly Earp turned around and bent over, sticking that cute little ass up in the air, presenting it for her big sister to fuck, and Wynonna just lost control again. Only this time it wasn't to a Demon possessing her. No, it was to her own selfish desires. Her selfish desires to butt fuck her baby sister. Although now, thankfully she had full control, and she was going to make sure that Waverly was as prepared as possible for this twisted act.
Namely, by burying her face in between those juicy ass cheeks and frantically licking her kid sister's most private hole. Something which made Waverly gasp, moan and whimper with seemingly pure delight, which was definitely a positive sign for what was to come. Although, in that moment Wynonna was too consumed with that tasty little hole to notice. Admittedly it wasn't quite as tasty as Waverly's pussy, but it was still a tasty little snack, one Wynonna savoured for a few long minutes, initially just sliding her tongue up and down that forbidden hole, before sliding her tongue all around it. Hell, at one point, she even shoved her tongue into it, anything to get ready for what was to come. Also, it was just fun.
Of course she didn't get very far with just her tongue, but she wasn't expecting too. In fact, barely being able to push a single bit inside was a plus, as it pretty much confirmed that Waverly was an anal virgin, and thus Wynonna would be the one to pop that cherry. Something that she was both aching to do as soon as possible, and quite happy to wait for eternity if it meant more time rimming her sweet Waverly. And not just because she wants to make it easier on her baby girl. No, Wynonna Earp proved that she was more twisted then anyone ever thought, which was really saying something, by becoming completely lost in munching her baby sister's yummy little butt.
So much so that she eventually heard a voice in her head telling her to 'get on with it'. And Wynonna always hated the idea of obeying commands, but she was willing to make an exception in this case, if it meant she had an excuse to violate her little sister's ass. So she pulled out her tongue and replaced it with her finger. The finger which she briefly popped into her mouth and sucked on, to prepare it for this tight little ass. The finger she slowly pushed into Waverly's butt hole, causing both sisters to cry out and then moan in pleasure in the process. Oh God, Waverly seemed to be loving it already, which was a very, very good sign. Something Wynonna couldn't help gloating about as she slowly buried that finger as far as it would go into her kid sister's back door, and then started pumping it in and out.
"You like that, baby girl?" Wynonna purred.
"Yes, mmmmmmmmm, I love it." Waverly moaned without hesitation, closing her eyes and biting her lip for a few long seconds, before adding, "It feels so good, ohhhhhhhhhh, and I want more."
"And you'll get it." Wynonna promised, "Just a sec, okay?"
"No, not okay. Do it now, Wynonna! Please?" Waverly whined, before looking over her shoulder and pleading, "Fuck me, oh please, fuck me Wynonna! Fuck my virgin ass hole! Fuck it, and make it your fuck hole! Please? I don't care if it hurts, I just need it right now! I need my ass to be yours. Won't you please take it? Mmmmmmmmm, take it and make it yours forever? Make me yours forever?"
There was a long pause, then Nicole whimpered, "Please Wynonna, don't do this. That's not Waverly talking, it's the Demon."
"No! This is me talking." Bad Waverly growled, before grinning wickedly, "Your precious little Waverly wants this, isn't that right, Waves?"
"I'm... I'm so sorry Nicole." Waverly whimpered when she had control back, and then looked away from her now ex-girlfriend and pleaded, "Please Wynonna, just do it. Fuck me. I want it! I need it. Please give it to me. Mmmmmmmm, Waverly needs her big sister to butt fuck her. Please? Oh please, fuck my butt, fuck me in the butt, ah fuck!"
"Spread your cheeks, baby girl." Bad Wynonna ordered, with an evil chuckle, "Show all three of us just how badly you want your shit hole filled with your big sister's cock! Mmmmmmmm, and how cute you look face down, your bitch hole stretching for this big dick. Ohhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhh, and don't take your eyes off of it, Officer Hottie, or I'll take it out on Waverly."
Waverly didn't hesitate to obey, pressing her face to the bed sheets and quickly reaching her hands backwards to grab two handfuls of her butt cheeks, before she slowly pulled them apart. She felt guilty about it, as the last thing she wanted to do was hurt Nicole. No. No, unfortunately that wasn't true. The last thing she wanted was for the Demon to kill any of them, which was still a strong possibility no matter what they did, but she had to at least try and save them. But, as much as she wanted to believe otherwise, the truth was, if there was no Demon, and she had to do this in front of Nicole if she wanted her ass fucked by her big sister, she would do it. Oh God, she would do anything, if she could get her ass fucked by Wynonna. Be Wynonna's.
Another rather unfortunate thing was that when she looked behind her, all she could really focus on was pitch black eyes, indicating it was the Demon who was enjoying the view, and then eventually pressed the tip of her cock against Waverly's back door. For a few horrible second she thought that it would be the Demon who would steal her anal cherry, literally from right underneath Wynonna's nose, but thankfully that didn't happen. Instead Wynonna finally got back control, and after only a brief hesitation she slowly pushed forwards, causing Waverly's virgin ass hole to start stretching for an invading object for the very first time. Something which made Waverly initially cry out, and then bite her lip to try to stop herself from doing it again, given that it caused her big sister to hesitate.
Thankfully that hesitation didn't last long, and Waverly felt her most private hole being stretched wider and wider, until the pain was almost unbearable. Almost, except for the fact that her eyes were locked with Wynonna's, which confirm this was a moment between the two sisters. Sure, that Demon was still watching them behind one of their eyes, and then there was poor Nicole, but in that moment as far as Waverly, and probably Wynonna, were concerned, there was just the two of them. And more importantly, the older sister's big dick was stretching the younger one's ass hole, until that virgin ring stretched wide enough for the head of that big strap-on to slide through it, and into Waverly's tailpipe.
Something which of course Wynonna had to gloat about, "It's in! Oh my God, baby girl, you just took me inside you. Inside your virgin ass! And you know what this means, right? Mmmmmmm yessssssssss, I got your anal cherry. Me! Wynonna Earp just took Waverly Earp's back door virginity, forever making her perfect little ass mine forever! You hear me Waverly? Your ass is mine! All mine! Ohhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhh, take it baby girl! Fucking take it! Mmmmmmmmm, fuck yeah, and make sure to take every inch. Every inch of my big dick. Oooooooooooooh yesssssssssss, take it, mmmmmmmmm fuckkkkkkkkkk, take it all the way up your tight little butt! All the way! Ah fuck! Ooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhh Goooooooooodddddddddddd!"
Poor little Waverly didn't offer up a retort. No, all she could do was lay there, whimpering and groaning, desperately trying to get use to the feeling of something so big stretching her butt hole wide open. Then, just as she thought she was making progress, Wynonna started slowly pushing forwards again, causing inch after inch of that big dildo to slide through Waverly's previously virgin back door and deep into her back passage. Something that made her wiggle and squirm, which failed to alleviate the pain. Which wasn't as bad as losing her ass cherry, but it was still pretty bad. And yet to her shame, she still found herself loving it. Probably just because it was Wynonna doing it, but still, it made her feel like such a slut. Which again, only added to her enjoyment.
Wynonna had done it! Waverly's anal cherry was hers! All hers! Her baby sister, her baby girl, and if she was honest, the woman she loved with all her heart, and she had just violated her in the most obscene way possible. Poor Wynonna was overwhelmed with those thoughts initially, so much so that she wasn't even sure what she was saying when she provided commentary. Or sure when she started pushing her hips forwards, causing inch after inch of that big dick to slide through Waverly's shit hole and deep into her shit-pipe, violating her in a way no girl was supposed to be taken. Luckily she was able to focus just enough to somewhat appreciate the beautiful sight in front of her, and the fact that Waverly, bless her heart, was still providing the best view of it, by continuing to spread her butt cheeks nice and wide.
Unluckily Waverly was whimpering and crying out with pure pain the entire time. And oh God, those sounds had been even worse during the butt hole stretching, especially when it stretched wide enough to allow her to take Waverly's back door cherry. It broke Wynonna's heart, and was unfairly the only thing which made her aware of everything else going on around her. Sadly she couldn't even offer to stop. Not with the Demon waiting to take control if she tried. Waiting to point out that she didn't want to stop. That Wynonna Earp was so sick and twisted, that she would do anything to sodomize her own sister, even if it hurt the one person she loved the most. Also Nicole, as she felt really bad about all this, but honestly in that moment, she pretty much forgot that the redhead existed.
That was especially true during the initial butt stuffing, anal sex, and of course, the moment her thighs came to rest against those ass cheeks, announcing that every single inch of her big dick was buried deep within Waverly's bowels. Oh God, she had done it. Waverly's butt cherry was undisputedly hers. It probably was before this, but now there was no argument. Especially when she actually began thrusting back and forth, officially giving her little sister her first ever taste of being properly fucked in the butt. Before that, of course, Wynonna just had to gloat some more. Although it took several long minutes for her to find her voice, as she was just so overwhelmed with lust.
"Congratulations baby girl, your ass is mine." Wynonna growled after what felt like an eternity, "Mmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhhh, every single inch of my big dick is buried up your tight little ass, making you mine forever. Oh yes, now every time you sit down, or stretch, or hell, take a fucking dump, you will remember this moment. Getting your ass opened up for the first time, by your big sister. Your big sister, burying her full-length inside your shit-pipe. Ohhhhhhhhhhhh yessssssssss, and the wonderful moment that she started treating you to your first ever ass fucking. The wonderful day I started treating you to your first ever ass fucking, right in front of your girlfriend. Oh fuck yeah Waverly, take it, mmmmmmmm, oooooooooooh fuckkkkkkkkkkk yeahhhhhhhhhh, take it up the butt, right in front of Nicole."
It was honestly hard to tell whether Wynonna was doing the talking, or it was the Demon. Either way, the result was the same, but Wynonna was pretty sure that she was doing it, if only so that the Demon wouldn't say or do worse. That was her excuse for everything she was doing right now, honestly. But the truth was, it might have been bitterness over the fact that Officer Hottie had got Waverly first in so many ways, and now, right in front of her, she was taking her baby sister in a way she never had been taken before. And more importantly, making Waverly hers forever. Which was toxic, and offensive, but in that moment Wynonna didn't care. Honestly, she didn't care about anything, other than her own satisfaction, and blaming it on the evil possessing the Earp sisters.
Waverly wasn't able to forget about Nicole, either because the Demon wanted her to remember her girlfriend the whole time, or because it was just so overwhelming. Either way, the result was the same, that she was bombarded by shame and humiliation at doing this in front of her girlfriend, who she truly loved. But she just didn't love her as much as her true love, Wynonna. Or as much as taking it up the butt. Oh God, to her surprise, and Wynonna's delight, Waverly Earp was very quickly proven to be a natural anal whore, as she let out sounds of pleasure, even during the pain of the butt stuffing. Then, shortly after the sodomy officially started, she let out a loud moan of pleasure.
Something which caused Wynonna to stop in disbelief, and then laugh with delight, "Wow, that's it baby girl, moan for me! Mmmmmmmmmm yessssssssssssss, moan as I ram your little shit hole! Oooooooooooooh yesssssssssssss, sweet little Waverly Earp, the good sister, loves it when her big sister slams her shitter, huh? Yeah she does, mmmmmmmmm fuck! Oh Waves, I can't believe you're this much of an anal whore. No wait, I can. Yeahhhhhhhhhhhh, with an ass like this, you couldn't be anything else. Yeahhhhhhhhhh, sweet little Waverly Earp has a perfect ass, which was made for fucking. And now, it's mine. All mine! Ooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssssss, take it, Wav! Take it and moan while I fuck you up the ass. Your perfect little ass. Aaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhh fuckkkkkkkkkkkkkkk, take it!"
Naturally, all these words, and sounds out of her mouth, caused Waverly to blush furiously. But she just couldn't stop making those sounds. No, if anything she made more of them, as whatever pain there had initially been faded away, leaving her with just pure pleasure. Pure, overwhelming pleasure, which had her aching for more. And she knew all she had to do was ask, and she would get it. But she didn't want too. At least, not right away. Partly because she didn't want to do that to Nicole, but if she was being honest, the main reason was because she wanted this to last forever. Oh yes, she was causing Nicole pain, so it wasn't perfect, but the Earp sisters were having sex, and Waverly never wanted it to end. It felt too good for that.
She'd always wanted to be with Wynonna, and now she was finally giving her big sister all of her. The most private part of her body. Making her Wynonna's forever. Wynonna's little anal bitch. Oh yes, no matter what happened after this, in this moment Waverly Earp truly felt like she belonged to Wynonna Earp, and that made her submissive little heart flutter. Also, she had no idea how much of an anal slut she was until these precious moments, and she wanted to have her big sister deep inside her slutty little butt forever. Or at least, for her slutty little back door to always be stretched from now on, so that she would be always ready for a butt fucking. Something she told her sibling, before begging to cum, as she just couldn't wait for it anymore.
"Fuck me, Wynonna! Fuck my tight little ass!" Waverly pleaded, interrupting her sister's constant commentary, "Mmmmmmmmmm, make sure my ass is never tight again. Make it a loose, used up fuck hole! Your fuck hole. Yours, to use whenever you want. Yessssssssssssssss, oooooooooooooooh yesssssssssssss, mmmmmmmmmmm, ruin my hole! Ruin me! Wreck my fucking butt hole! Oh please, OH WYNONNA, OOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS, FUCK ME! FUCK ME HARDER AND MAKE ME CUM! CUM LIKE A BITCH WITH A DICK IN MY ASS! MAKE ME YOURS FOREVER! YOUR BITCH, AAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHH FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK, OH WYNONNA, I WANNA BE YOUR ANAL BITCH! WYNONNA EARP'S ANAL BITCH! AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDD!"
Unsurprisingly, it didn't take much for Wynonna to give her what she wanted. Which in this case, was an increase to the strength and the power behind the butt fucking which maybe literally became a rectum wrecking, and seemingly in the blink of an eye. Something which should have had anyone begging for mercy, but instead Waverly was screaming in ecstasy, her cum shooting definitely out of her cunt and her body trembling. Hell, she even lifted herself up onto all fours, and started slamming herself back against that weapon of ass destruction. Anything to give her more pleasure, and hopefully her big sister too. Also, make it crystal clear that she really was Wynonna's bitch. Her big sister's anal bitch.
.
Wynonna also wanted to make it crystal clear that Waverly was her anal bitch. No, she needed it. She needed Waverly to know that this perfect ass of hers now belong to her big sister. That The Earp Heir now owned her baby sister's butt hole. It was her fuck hole, that Wynonna could use for her pleasure whenever she wanted. Which were all things she desperately wanted to say, or more accurately, needed to say, but at first she couldn't, simply because she had to concentrate on dishing out the hardest butt pounding she was capable of. One far harder than she'd ever dare give before, just to make it crystal clear that Waverly really was hers. And maybe more importantly, to make her baby girl cum as hard and as frequently as possible.
The entire time she was worried about the Demon taking over, and ruining what was probably the best moment of her life. Or at least, one of them, as it really did feel like she was laying claim to Waverly, and truly making her kid sister hers forever. And better yet, the good sister clearly wanted this as badly as she did, given how frantically she was hammering her cute little booty back at her. Thankfully, not only did the Demon not take over, but it actually seemed to lend the older sibling, and possibly the younger one too, some of it strength, so that the Earps could truly make this a rectum wrecking. Which was kind of the final straw for poor Wynonna, who just had to start dishing out some verbal encouragement.
"CUM ! CUM FOR ME, YOU LITTLE BITCH!" Wynonna yelled, grabbing hold of Waverly's hair and yanking back on it while smacking that perfect little booty, and adding, "OH YES! OOOOOOOOOOOOOH YESSSSSSSSSS, CUM FOR ME, AND BE MY BITCH! OH YES, YOU'RE MY BITCH, WAVES! YOU'RE WYNONNA EARP'S LITTLE ANAL BITCH, MMMMMMMMM, WITH A PERFECT LITTLE ASS, WHICH IS NOW MINE TO FUCK! ALL MINE! OHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH YEAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH, TAKE IT, WAV! TAKE IT LIKE THE ANAL BITCH YOU ARE! AH FUCK, TAKE IT BITCH! AAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHH FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSS, OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH GOOOOOOOOOOOOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!"
Of course, all of that combined with the other end of the dildo hitting her clit, the sound, and the feeling of those meaty cheeks jiggling for her, and the sheer joy of sodomizing her sister, AKA, the person she loved the most in the world, made Wynonna cum so wonderfully hard. Thankfully she had plenty of practice dishing out this kind of thing, and was able to push herself through it, and make herself cum multiple times the process. Although that was truly out of instinct, as she pretty much lost her mind on that first orgasm. Probably before then, if she was really honest with herself. Then there was nothing but her and Waverly. Then, not even that. No, there was a strap-on dildo literally trying to ruin a butt hole, and that was it.
The next thing Wynonna was really aware of, was laying on top of Waverly, the two of them clearly having just collapsed with exhaustion onto the bed below, after what seemed like countless orgasms. And yet, Wynonna was still fucking her sister's shit hole. It was a little slower now, and might've been the result of aftershocks echoing through her body. Or at least, that was the reason for them. Whatever the case, this put an explanation point on her ownership of the fuck hole, otherwise known as Waverly Earp's ass hole, so she was finding it hard to stop. Not even when she became visibly aware of poor, broken-hearted Officer Nicole Haught staring at them with disbelief.
Nicole prayed to anyone who would listen that she would wake up from this nightmare, but as time ticked by, it became crystal clear, this wasn't merely her worst fear of losing Waverly to a Demon, somehow combining one where she lost her to Wynonna. No, this was really happening. And sure, a Demon had possessed the woman she loved to put them in this position, but there was no sign of that Demon now. No, this was two sisters having sex in front of her, in the most twisted way possible, completely breaking her poor heart in the process. And possibly Waverly's ass hole, given the abuse that poor hole took during that hard pounding. At least then their eyes flashed black, proving that the Demon was helping with the sodomy, but not being the primary force behind it.
Then all of a sudden, Wynonna's eyes went dark black, she grinned wickedly at the police officer, and then yanked Waverly's head up by the hair, and growled, "Who's bitch are you, baby girl?"
"Ah fuck!" Waverly cried out, and then whimpered with her eyes closed, "Wynonna's! Oh God, I'm Wynonna's bitch. Mmmmmmmmm, I am my big sister's anal bitch."
"No!" Bad Wynonna snapped, yanking on Waverly's hair again, and then demanding, "Look your girlfriend in the eyes, and tell her what you are."
"Ah fuck!" Waverly cried out again, then after only a brief hesitation, she looked Nicole in the eye, and repeated herself, "I'm Wynonna's! Oh God, I'm Wynonna's bitch. Sorry Nicole, but I'm my big sister's anal bitch."
"Good bitch." Bad Wynonna laughed, before yanking her dick out of Waverly's ass and demanded, "Now prove it! Mmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhhh, prove it by sucking big sister's dick. Ooooooooooooh yesssssssssssssssss, suck your big sister's ass flavoured dick, and get every drop of your own butt cream. Right in front of your girl."
"I'm sorry, Nicole." Waverly whimpered, before moving to do as she was told.
"Hey, don't apologize to her." Bad Wynonna scolded, before grinning wickedly, moving beside Nicole, and ordering, "Just for that, you can spread your cheeks, and show me and your girlfriend, your sister's handiwork. Ohhhhhhhhhhhh yessssssssssss, show us that gape. Which, BTW, was all Wynonna. Oooooooooooh yessssssssssss, Wynonna Earp just gaped Waverly Earp's ass hole! And it looks soooooooooo pretty. Oooooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhh, just you wait, Officer Hottie. You're in for a real treat. Mmmmmmmmmm, fuck yeah, spread those cheeks for me just like that, bitch! Ooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhh fuckkkkkkkkkkkkkkk!"
Having Waverly apologized for her behaviour was far too little, far too late. Especially considering what she'd been about to do, and still probably would do. And what she was doing now. Oh God, the girl who had seemed so sweet and innocent when Nicole had first met her, lifted her big booty into the air, faced her audience, and then reached back to spread her cheeks, exposing herself obscenely. More to the point in that moment, exposing just how open her poor little butt hole was. And the Demon was getting off on it, because of course it was, but it was looked like it was the same thing for the Earps. Especially Wynonna, who seemed to be back to herself. Well, at least for the moment.
"Do as that thing said, Wav..." Wynonna said softly, after a few long minutes of staring deep into her sister's bowels via that gaping crater that was her butt hole, "Suck my dick."
"Yes, Wynonna." Waverly softly replied and obeyed, this time without hesitation.
She even moaned happily from the first taste of her butt, to the last. And she sucked it even more enthusiastically than before, once again showing just how much of a slut the girl Nicole had mistaken as sweet and innocent was. God, the redhead wanted to look away from the twisted brunettes, but she couldn't. She just couldn't. No, she stared in disbelief as Waverly Earp savoured the taste of the deepest part of her butt, and then very slowly worked her way down the shaft, until she had the entire length in her throat, just to get every drop of that liquid. Then when it was completely clean, Wynonna Earp pulled her little sister up into a passionate kiss, and Nicole once again had to watch the woman she loved making out with her sister.
"Now, which one of you should I keep?" Bad Wynonna question with an evil chuckle, "Oh, ha ha, I know..."
Confident in it's victory, the evil creature once again initiated a kiss, then jumped back and forth between the sisters in a twisted game of eny meany miny moe. Then all of a sudden, Wynonna was flipping Waverly onto her back, grabbing a flask from her discarded jacket, and then pouring the contents down her baby sister's throat. Waverly then puked out the Demon, Wynonna shot it, and then the two siblings cradled each other, understandably crying after everything they had been through. And what almost happened. Nicole was crying too, but it wasn't the same, as she was left feeling numb inside, and wishing that it was her taking a bullet to the head. Especially as she found herself locking eyes with the Earps. Those bad, bad Earps.
- 3
- 4
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

Bad Earps