Adult-FanFiction.org : Television / Streaming

Tutoring Tutor Girl	By : MTL Category: M through R > One Tree Hill Views: 25454 -:- Recommendations : 0 -:- Currently Reading : 1
Disclaimer: I do not own The One Tree Hill, nor any of the characters from it. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.

Chapter List
- 6
- 7
- 8
Haley James Scott cautiously entered the home of possibly her least favourite person in the world Rachel Gatina. It wasn't that long ago she couldn't have imagined entering this home under any circumstances, but that was before her best friend Brooke Davis had started living here. More importantly that was before that same Brooke Davis, the best female friend she ever had and the most popular girl in her school, had talked her into a sexual relationship where she was Brooke's bitch and thus forced to obey her commands whatever they may be.
The thing was the last time she had obeyed an order which was allegedly from Brooke to come to this house she found Rachel, the girl who had been trying to steal her husband, waiting for her and they'd had sex. No, scratch that, Rachel had fucked her in just about every sense of the word, humiliating her almost beyond belief, and to her shame Haley had loved it. So as she slowly opened the unlocked door and then closed and locked it behind her as the text she had received had instructed her to do Haley wondered who exactly had ordered her here, and what exactly would happen when she got to the bed room Brooke and Rachel shared.
Naturally Haley had been wondering that since she received the text, but now her mind was racing extra fast, her heart pounding in her chest as she ascended the stairs. Honestly Haley wasn't sure who she'd prefer. Probably Brooke. She was her best friend and then there was the part that when they had sex Brooke always made her feel so loved and cared for... but at the same time there was just something about Rachel. The way she had abused her, oh Haley couldn't stop thinking about it, the images of her last time with the redhead making her so wet.
Of course it was nothing compared to how she felt when she received the answer to her question, Haley kind of guessing as she heard soft cries and a weird smacking sound as she approached her destination. Still, to poked her head into Brooke's bed room and find her best friend bent over the knee of the total bitch, Rachel Gatina spanking Brooke Davis right in front of her... Haley honestly couldn't put into words how obscene that was. And to her shame, just how much it turned her on.
Brooke was unaware that Haley was there, but she did know her arrival was imminent. It was the main reason her pussy was so wet, because sure, getting her ass spanked was more of a turn on that she could have ever imagined. But there was just something about getting caught which drove her wild. And this wasn't like all those times she had talked Peyton, and/or Haley into having sex with her in the girls locker room or the toilets at school, or even a friend's house. No, this time someone was walking in on her getting her naked butt beaten like a disobedient child. And it just so happened to be the girl who had been the first to catch her in the act and the start of a chain of events which led her to this very pleasurable point. Well, sort of pleasurable.
There was still definitely a lot of pain, especially because every so often Rachel would smack her ass with what had to be all her might, and even a gentle spanking from her rival made it hard for Brooke to sit down. Or harder, given all the constant butt fuckings Brooke was taking from now both Peyton and Rachel, Brooke honestly unable to remember what it was like to sit down without wincing. The only difference was just how sore her ass was, and given the current butt beating she was receiving the answer to that was bad, but not that bad.
It helped that Rachel not only stopped in between each strike and thus gave Brooke time to recover but she shamelessly groped the brunette's butt, and caressing at least some of the pain away. True, Rachel blatantly did that for her own enjoyment, having confessed as much only a few minutes ago, but that in turn only made Brooke enjoy it more. And she loved being used for another girl's pleasure.
Of course when Haley got here Brooke's enjoyment was going to at least double, the cheerleader captain dreaming of all the fun they have when one member of her squad finally got here while another member continued spanking and groping her captain's butt with glee. Then when Brooke did finally spot Haley she grinned so widely that her dimples were on full display, her body going from tingling in anticipation to practically burning with it.
Given their positions, and the fact that she was constantly looking for her, it wasn't surprising that Rachel was the first one to spot Haley watching them. Although to be fair it wasn't like Haley was doing a particularly good job of hiding herself. In fact it look like she wasn't even trying, only occasionally ducking her head out of sight when she clearly thought Rachel was going to look up, the allegedly smart tutor apparently completely unaware that Rachel had spotted her the moment she had arrived. Rachel just hadn't reacted to it because she was finding this so amusing.
Using the situation to her advantage Rachel began picking up the pace of the spanking, making the hard blow to Brooke's perfect butt more frequent and sometimes concentrating on one specific spot to make sure she had her rival turned bitch crying out loudly for her. It helped that she had already turned Brooke's butt cheeks a cute little pink colour since she had bent the other girl over her knee about fifteen, twenty minutes ago in preparation for Haley's arrival, that flawless flesh quickly turning a rosy red under the assault.
Then and only then did Rachel look up and give Haley a wicked smile, "Hey there tutor girl, what kept you?"
Ignoring the question Haley turned to her friend and asked, "What's going on? Brooke, are you alright?"
"I'm fine Hales." Brooke beamed from her place over Rachel's knee, "Rach was just showing me who's boss."
"Oh God." Haley murmured her disbelief, her pussy dampening as her fears were realised.
"That's right bitch, I'm showing you who's boss." Rachel praised the bitch over her knee before turning her attention back to the bitch now cautiously walking into the room for a better look at what was going on, "And I'm about to do the same to you Haley. Mmmmmmm, I'm about to spank that ass of yours. Just. Like. This."
To emphasise her point Rachel dished out three extra hard spanks to coincide with the last three words. As she did that she looked directly into Haley's eyes, another wicked grin crossing her face as she watched the stuck up tutor with every blow she gave their mutual friend's butt. The temptation to keep spanking Brooke just like that while staring a hole into Haley's soul was almost overwhelming, but Rachel's hand was already tired and she wanted to save her strength for both spanking Haley and more importantly fucking the two other girls.
So she forced herself to stop and then, after groping Brooke's butt for a couple more seconds, Rachel pushed her captain unceremoniously off of her lap and onto the floor, giggling wickedly as the supposed Queen Bee of their school crying out first in surprise and then in pain, Brooke clutching her well beaten ass and scowling at the redhead for a few long seconds. Then when she returned the look with a glare of her own Brooke lowered her head in submission, causing Rachel to chuckle again before turning her attention back to Haley.
"Well, what are you waiting for bitch? Bend over my knee already!" Rachel ordered, patting her knee invitingly.
"Why should I?" Haley grumbled, crossing her arms.
"Oh I don't know..." Rachel said mockingly, "Maybe because you don't want me to tell your husband about you slutting it up with two girls behind his back? Or should I say three girls?"
"I wouldn't count you." Haley grumbled, turning her head away slightly.
"I would, especially now I've decided to make this a regular thing." Rachel grinned.
Haley raised an eyebrow, "I thought you weren't gay?"
"I'm not." Rachel quickly replied before smiling, "You two are gonna be the dyke sluts licking my cunt. I'm just going to have some fun dominating your skanky asses. Mmmmmmm, speaking of which, get over here, so I can give you a nice hard spanking, or I'll call up Nathan and tell him just how much you love my pussy."
Seeing Haley open her mouth to protest Brooke quickly chimed in, "Just do it Hales. We all know you want too."
Haley looked back and forth between Brooke and Rachel for a few long seconds, then she let out a groan of frustration and stomped over to where the redhead was sitting. She stopped in front of her for a second, Haley getting to tower over someone for a change, the bitch just grinning up at her, confident she knew what Haley was going to do. And she was right, although Haley was very tempted just to smack Rachel across the face and leave. However, that might cost Haley her marriage, and if she was honest with herself she wanted this bitch to spank her ass and then fuck her like the little lesbian slut she had become.
"Yeah, that's right bitch." Rachel grinned, "We'll teach you your proper place yet."
Despite the very strong urge to say something back what could Haley possibly say? Rachel had her right where she wanted her and all Haley could do was take a calming breath and wait for the butt beating to begin. Unfortunately Rachel was in no hurry to do that, reaching out and grabbing Haley's ass and then squeezing and pinching it like it was a piece of meat. Haley was pretty sure she continued insulting her too, although she did her best to block that part out.
Then came the pain. Not much at first, but the suddenness of the first blow had Haley crying out. She gritted her teeth and dug fingernails into the palm of her hands to try and stop herself from crying out again, or at least minimising her cries of anguish, but it was no use. Rachel was clearly determined to make her scream, and eventually she succeeded. Haley was proud that she didn't succeed until the spanking really got going. However making the bitch work for it wasn't much of a consolation when she was bent over Rachel's lap with the redhead relentlessly striking her ass like she was a naughty child.
What did make it better was that Haley felt like she deserved this. After all, she had become addicted to lesbian sex after allowing her best female friend to seduce her, pretty much becoming the lezzie slut of three women. The whole time she was still in love with Nathan, but as much as she loved her husband she just couldn't stop fucking other women. Therefore, every time one of her lesbian lovers bent her over their knee, she thought maybe she deserved this. Maybe she deserved every blow she was getting, the pain of the spanking therapeutic, especially when Rachel spanked her as unlike the two women she was actually friends with the redhead didn't hold back.
Rachel enjoyed teasing Haley at first, but she definitely had the most fun brutalising Haley's butt, a huge grin on her face the entire time she watched that pale flesh slowly but surely turned red under the assault. And by the time she was even considering stopping it was bruised and a dark, angry red, Haley literally weeping pathetically without a hint of her former pride. Honestly Rachel couldn't get enough of it, enjoying the hell out of watching the high and mighty, and supposedly innocent, little teenage wife reduced to tears thanks to her methodical strikes.
The only downside was Rachel was concerned at the looks she was getting from Brooke, and even then she wasn't sure why she cared about them. Or why she somewhat showed Haley some mercy after she first caught a glance of them. Although it wasn't much, Rachel simply massaging Haley's butt in between spanks, and while this caressed away some of the physical pain she clearly continued to make Haley suffer as she whimpered with humiliation as Rachel went back and forth between treating her ass like a piece of meat and a punching bag.
All of this made Rachel embarrassingly horny, and that, more than the looks she was getting from Brooke, caused her to push Haley roughly off of her lap and then stand up, quickly tear off her clothes and order Brooke, "Eat me!"
Grinning happily Brooke quickly stepped forward, dropped to her knees in front of Rachel and buried her face in her pussy. Rachel then closed her eyes and let out a long moan as her friend began licking her pussy with rapid and eager swipes of her tongue, the redhead just enjoying the sensation for a few long minutes. After all, she was wet and ready for it, so why shouldn't she enjoy it? What did she have to worry about at this stage? Oh, right... Haley, Rachel opening her eyes and smirking down at her rival as she brought her hand up to the top of Brooke's head, tangled her fingers in her pretty brown hair and pulled her into her cunt.
The redhead then began taunting both of the brunettes, "Oh yeah Brooke, eat me. Eat my pussy you nasty little dyke! Fucking eat me out! Ohhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhh, lick my pussy just like your slutty little tutor bitch! Mmmmmmmmm, I bet you wish this was you, don't you Hales? Mmmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhhh, I bet you wish this was your face buried in my pussy, licking my fucking cunt like the little rug muncher you are! Ooooooooooooh yessssssssssss, you wanna lick me, I can tell, ooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh, and you're in luck, because I have another hole you can lick! Oh yeah bitch, I want you to lick my ass while your best buddy licks my pussy! Come on, don't be shy. Get behind me and become my little ass kisser! Oooooooooohhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhh, I want Haley James Scott to become my ass kisser."
While Haley looked appropriately appalled by this order, but to Rachel's surprise she slowly crawled behind her without too much fuss. Haley even took the hint and started off by pressing her lips to Rachel's ass cheeks, literally becoming her ass kisser in the process, a fact Rachel delighted in taunting the other girl about. Although truth be told thanks to the combination of those two female mouths working on her most intimate areas it wasn't long before Rachel had little clue what she was babbling on about because she was just so lost in the pleasure that Brooke and Haley were giving her.
Brooke was delighted at the chance of tasting Rachel's pussy again, and would have love to have given a long drawn-out cunt licking. However it quickly became very clear Rachel wasn't interested in slow and gentle, and honestly after the rough treatment she'd already received, and watched Haley receive, Brooke didn't object to returning the favour with the roughest pussy licking she could dish out. That involved grazing her teeth against Rachel's clit, which bizarrely the other girl seemed to enjoy just as much as Brooke's soft lips and tongue attacking that sensitive area. Then, shortly after Haley kneeled down behind Rachel, the redhead gave Brooke the permission she had been waiting for.
"Ohhhhhhhhhhh yesssssssssssssss, fuck me, mmmmmmmmmm, fuck me you dyke!" Rachel cried out joyfully, "Ooooooooooooh fuck my pussy, fuck my ass, aaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhh fuck, yes fuck, fuck my fucking fuck holes! Mmmmmmmmmm, fuck them with your tongues! Fuck my cunt and my butt with your little dyke tongue! Yeeeeeeeeeeessssssssssssss, get both those tongues inside me and fuck me like a slutty little lezzie whore! Oooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeeessssssssssssss, aaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhh Gooooooooooodddddddddd, Brooke! Fuck me Brooke! Oh Haley, oooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh aaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh fuckkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk!"
Happily obliging Brooke slowly pushed her tongue as deep as it would go into Rachel's cunt. She then left it there for almost a full minute so she could just enjoyed the feeling of Rachel quivering around her tongue. Then she began thrusting that soft wet muscle in and out of her friend/rival, making Rachel scream and buck her hips into Brooke's face. Rachel also shoved Brooke's face as deep into her cunt as possible with a firm grip on the back of her hair, which was kind of painful, but also a hell of turn on for Brooke, and it did make sure her tongue went nice and deep, so it was mostly a win-win.
Brooke also liked the fact that Rachel's other hand was pushing Haley's face as deep as it would go into her ass, encouraging her formally prudish friend to eat her other friend's ass out with as much passion as she could muster. Which was a lot, Brooke just about able to feel Haley's tongue invading Rachel's butt through the thin wall separating the redhead's front and back passages, making it official two cheerleaders were in fact tongue fucking a third at the same time, Brooke kind of wishing they were all wearing their uniforms as that visual would have been incredible. Not that it was bad in it's current form, Brooke wishing Peyton was here so she could take pictures. Or better yet be in Brooke's position so Brooke could get a good look at this wonderful sight.
Then again Brooke wasn't so sure she wanted to give up her current position, especially as she was soon receiving a mouthful of girl cum, most of which she was proud to say she swallowed. She wasn't so fortunate with the following climaxes, although most of that ended up on her face which gave her a wicked thrill, meaning she enjoyed this almost as much as Rachel. Especially as after Rachel's fourth orgasm Brooke just couldn't resist reaching between her legs and rubbing herself to an orgasm of her own, while of course still doing her best to tongue fuck Rachel through her climaxes.
Rachel was embarrassed how hard and frequently she came. After all, she was supposed to be straight and here she was cumming harder, and a lot more times, then with any guy. At least this time round she not only had the excuse of fucking the hottest girl in school, but two girls at the same time. Two girls who were clearly total pussy loving dyke sluts who gobbled each other's cunts, and asses, whenever they could. Besides, she was being assaulted from behind, as well as in front, a talented tongue in her pussy and ass at the same time, so what choice did Rachel have but to cum hard and frequently?
Anyone probably would from being given such passionate oral sex while receiving an equally skilful rim job. Or at least that was what Rachel told herself before and after she became completely lost in the ecstasy she was receiving, Rachel coming very close to passing out. The only reasons she didn't was because she was likely to fall and hurt herself. And more importantly she wanted to strap-on fuck at least one, and ideally both, of these girls. So reluctantly Rachel reached down, grabbed two handfuls of long hair and pulled the two other girls away from her pussy and ass, stepped aside and pushed their faces together.
"Kiss!" Rachel growled, barely getting the word out before Brooke and Haley did just that, "Oh yes, kiss and taste me on your tongues you nasty bitches! Mmmmmmm yeah, taste my cum Haley! Taste it on Brooke's tongue. Taste that cum on her tongue while Brooke tastes my ass on yours. Yesssssssss, that's it Brooke, taste my fucking butt on your precious tutor girl's tongue! Oh fuck, that's so hot."
Even though Rachel continued to provide commentary and kept her hands on the other girl's heads for a little while it was completely unnecessary, something Haley and Brooke proved when Rachel let go of them completely and moved back and yet her fellow cheerleaders kept passionately making out with each other. They continued doing so as Rachel retrieved the same strap-on she'd previously used to fuck both these girls and slowly strapped it on while keeping her eyes glued to where Brooke and Haley were kissing. God, I feel so straight now, Rachel thought sarcastically. Desperately ignoring that thought Rachel cleared her throat to get the attention of the other girls.
"Hey bitches, over here!" Rachel snapped when that didn't work, then smirking as she saw Brooke look excited, and Haley apprehensive, when they saw her newly attached cock, "Yeah, that's right. You two sluts remember this, right? Well now I want the two of you to lube me up with a nice long blow job. Come on bitches, don't just kneel there looking stupid, suck my cock! Oh yes, that's it Brooke, mmmmmmmmm, why am I not surprised you were first? Actually, I'm surprised you didn't need to shove Haley out of the way you're both such cock sucking sluts. Especially for strap-on cocks. Oh yeah, you two are sluts for strap-ons, and tonight you're definitely going to be sluts for my strap-on."
As Rachel chuckled and continued taunting as Brooke eagerly began bobbing her head up and down the shaft, after previously having shuffled forwards quickly on her knees so she was once again kneeling in front of Rachel and wrapping her 'blow job lips' around Rachel's strap-on. Like Rachel said, it wasn't surprising, Brooke having proven to be an eager cock sucker ever since they started fucking, just like Rachel had always suspected she was. However Rachel didn't want Brooke to do all the work. No, she wanted a blow job from both her fellow cheerleaders, so just as Brooke started to shove the shaft down her throat Rachel stopped her.
"Now Brooke, don't hog that cock all to yourself." Rachel scolded her friend before looking up at the girl she didn't really care for, "Give Haley a turn."
Brooke let out a groan of frustration. Rachel was right, she loved sucking cock, especially strap-on cock, and she wanted to hog that cock all to herself. However she also wanted to see Haley suck Rachel's cock, so reluctantly Brooke pulled back and looked at Haley expectedly. The advantage to that Brooke got an close look at Haley awkwardly shuffling forwards and wrapping her mouth around Rachel's dildo, the once innocent tutor girl then beginning to bob her head up and down the dildo while Rachel provided her usual encouragement.
"Yes, that's it tutor girl, suck my cock!" Rachel demanded, "Suck it better than you suck your husband's cock you little slut! Mmmmmmmmm, that's it, take it deep! Take it deep into your mouth and down your fucking throat you little bitch. Oh yes, you look so good with a cock in your mouth tutor girl. I always thought you would."
Despite everything that they had done already those words made Haley blush in a way the Brooke found incredibly cute. Of course those words also had the obviously desired effect of making Haley suck that cock even more eagerly, and easier for her take more of it into her mouth, and eventually down her throat. Which in turn made Brooke a little jealous. But it was possible for her to complain when she was watching the formerly innocent little Haley James Scott choke on a dick she was willingly stuffing into her throat as the wicked Rachel Gatina continued to provide commentary to this until she decided to change things up.
"Ok, now swap." Rachel ordered, and when Haley looked up at her instead of obeying right away Rachel simply shrugged, "What, I said I wanted a blow job from both of you. Now get to it."
Hesitantly Haley did as she was told, as soon as she removed her mouth from that dildo Brooke eagerly took over, this time showing off her deep throating skills right off the bat by swallowing the entire strap-on cock as quickly as she could. She then briefly savoured the wonderfully slutty feeling of a dick in her throat before she began bobbing her head up and down, pretty much fucking her own mouth on the shaft. From the sounds of it Rachel very much enjoyed this for quite a while, before she made Haley take over again and do her best to copy Brooke, the two brunettes taking into it in turns to suck that strap-on for quite a while until Rachel decided it was time to move on.
"Yeah, suck it sluts! Suck it like the cock suckers you are! Mmmmmmmmm, come on Haley, you can take it deeper than that. Yes, that's it... now Brooke, you take over. Oh, you are a greedy little cock whore aren't you? Ohhhhhhhhhh yeah, Brooke Davis is a total whore. Well, everybody already knows that, but I have to admit, oooooooooooh, it’s nice to see the proof right in front of my eyes. Mmmmmmmmm, but I don't want you to hog it, so... Haley, you take over now. Yeahhhhhhhhhhh, show me why your husband is so patient with you while you go out dyking around town and eating any pussy you can get your hands on. Oh yeah, you're both such dyke sluts! Pussy and strap-on loving sluts, ah fuck, who can't get enough of my girl cock!" Rachel demanded, then after saying a bunch of other things she finally ordered, "Ok, that should be enough lube for your slutty asses... Haley, get in the centre of the bed. I want you face down and ass up. It's time to really show you who's boss."
Seeing her friend's apprehension Brooke piped up, "Can I lick her ass first? Haley is still new to anal, and I love eating ass. Please? I promise to put on a good show for you."
Rachel thought for moment, and then shook her head, "Na, my dick is wet enough, and I want her to really feel it when I violate her little hole."
"Please Rachel." Haley whimpered, "I, I don't think I can take it unless I'm properly prepared."
"Oh trust me, you'll take it." Rachel grinned wickedly, and then added, "But I suppose if you are a good girl and get into position, and spread your cheeks, I'll let Brooke spit on your back door a little."
For a few long seconds Haley and Rachel stared at each other, then the tutor girl lowered her head, rolled onto the bed and then after getting in the centre of it pressed her face down, reached back and spread her butt cheeks. In what felt like a second Brooke was behind her, eagerly spitting on her best friend's butt hole, at first as many times as she could before concentrating on making it as wet and sloppy as possible, literally drooling onto the whole amount to be violated. As she had spent the last few weeks personally hammering Haley's ass with her strap-on Brooke was confident that her friend could take it, and more importantly enjoy it, but she couldn't help worry that Rachel would be a little too roughly with this. Not that stop her from moving away when Rachel told her to and then eagerly watching one of her fellow cheerleaders sodomising another.
"Ok, that's enough Brooke. Move out of the way so I can wreck Haley James Scott's stuck up ass!" Rachel ordered, quickly taking Brooks place at the first opportunity before taunting, "Last time I took it easy on you. Now I am really going to make you my whore. And who knows, if I really enjoy fucking this whore ass of yours, I may keep you around as a piece of ass on the side while I fuck your husband. Oh yes, you're mine now bitch, and soon your husband will be too."
Haley gritted her teeth, unable to believe that she was actually giving up her ass to Rachel. It was so humiliating, and yet perversely thrilling, to submit to this bitch who had been trying to fuck her husband pretty much since they met, and now she was going to take it up the ass for her and be her little bitch. Something which of course Rachel couldn't help but remind her of, the bitch rubbing it in as she rubbed the tip of her dildo up and down Haley's ass crack.
"Mmmmmm, that's it bitch, give me that sweet ass!" Rachel taunted gleefully, "Give me this sweet little ass which you never let your husband touch but is now my personal fuck hole. Mmmmmm, I bet he begged you for this didn't he? Begged you to just let him try it, mmmmmmm, just slide into this little hole and see how it feels? Your tight little ass hole squeezing his dick so good, mmmmmmm, but you wouldn't let him would you? No, you didn't want him to fuck this dyke ass. You wanted Brooke to do it. You wanted me to do it. You're a lesbian slut Haley James Scott, and you wanted to be butt fucked by girls. And now... you're gonna be!"
Ignoring the obnoxious redhead Haley concentrated on keeping herself as relaxed as possible, knowing that chances are Rachel was just waiting for her to get annoyed and tense up so she could slam that strap-on into her back hole and cause her the maximum amount of pain possible. Well Haley wasn't going to give her satisfaction of that. Although when she was finally anally penetrated Haley did let out a loud cry of both pain and pleasure as her ass hole was quickly and violently forced open to accept a couple of very thick inches of dildo inside it.
For better or for worse, Brooke and Peyton had been making sure Haley didn't go a single day without a nice hard butt fucking, Brooke being of course the one to most regularly bend her over, so by now Haley was used to having a cock stretch open her back door. However Brooke and Peyton were her friends and always penetrated her slowly and gently, and while Haley hadn't been expecting the same kind of mercy from her hated rival the level of force Rachel used to violate her ass hole took her by surprise.
Which caused Brooke to call out, "Hey, take it easy."
Smirking wickedly Rachel said, "Sure thing Brooke. I'll take it easy on your slut."
Poor Haley was worried that Rachel wasn't going to live up to her word given her tone of voice, but the redhead gave her ass one long and slow thrust in which about half of the dildo ended up buried inside the brunette's butt, then she started pumping her hips back and forth and officially started to sodomise her. Rachel officially started to sodomise Haley, and despite herself Haley found herself moaning in mostly pleasure as her rectum slowly got used to being a fuck passage for Rachel Gatina's pleasure.
Rachel had been pretty much grinning since she had bent Brooke over her knee and gave her that long spanking, but it became dangerously wide when she anally penetrated that stuck up bitch Haley James Scott. It continued to be dangerously wide as she officially began butt fucking her new little bitch, those little cries of pleasure and/or pain that Haley was now constantly letting out like the sweetest music to Rachel's ears while her eyes locked on to were her dildo first invaded and then started pumping in and out of sweet little Haley James Scott's ass hole.
Perhaps the most perverted part of her new favourite hobby in the world was how much she was fascinated by butt holes, Rachel unable to get enough of watching another girl's butt hole stretching for her strap-on. It was so gross and so wrong, Rachel inwardly disgusted with herself, but watching a cock strapped round her waist forcing another girl's most private hole open like that gave her such a feeling of dominance. For some reason she felt like the strap-on was an extension of herself, that it was her very own cock she was plunging deep inside another girl's tightest orifice, violating her in such a way which meant whatever else happened later in this moment the other girl was her bitch.
Of course, it wouldn't be just this moment, because as far as Rachel was concerned Haley James Scott was now her bitch. This annoying girl who had given her so much grief was her own personal sex slave, the second in her new collection to go along with Brooke Davis and soon Peyton Sawyer, and while the other girls were hotter in her opinion it was almost overwhelmingly gratifying to sodomise this uppity little know it all, Rachel having to use every ounce of self-restraint to make sure she kept the ass fucking nice and slow to begin with.
After all she didn't want to literally ruin Haley's ass, not before she had her fun with this little bitch. So Rachel kept a slow and steady pace, pumping inch after inch of dildo into Haley's butt hole until her thighs smacked against the other girl's butt cheeks which Haley was still spreading. Then without pausing for a second Rachel began to butt fuck Haley with the full length of the toy cock, plunging it as deep as it would go into Haley's bowels with every thrust and making her new slut moan loudly with what was now pure pleasure.
Which of course Rachel couldn't just ignore, "Ohhhhhh yeahhhhhhh, moan for me bitch! Moan for me while I'm fucking your tight little ass! Mmmmmmm yeah, moan like a whore. Moan like an anal whore! Moan like, ha, moan like Brooke Davis, the biggest anal whore in Tree Hill!"
Hearing these words had Brooke grinning wickedly and happily joining in the fun, "Oh Hales, moan like the anal whore you know we both are! Mmmmmmm, we both know I'm the biggest anal whore in Tree Hill, but I've turned you into a close second, haven't I? Ooooooooh yeah, I popped your little anal cherry and turned you into my personal anal whore, and now because of that your Rachel's. Your Rachel's anal whore because of me! Because of me, your best friend, you're gonna have to bend over and give up your ass to the girl you hate most in this world and be her personal anal whore, and you're going to love it because naughty little tutor girl can't get enough of being fucked in the ass like a total slut!"
Initially Haley just whimpered and moaned in response, but that wasn't enough for Rachel who grabbed a firm hold of Haley's hair, yanked it so forcefully it caused the other girl to let go of her cheeks and lift her head up, then she lent down to practically screaming her ear, "Is that right tutor girl? Are you a total slut who can't get enough of being fucked in the ass? Huh? Are you so addicted to being butt fucked you just can't wait to be my personal anal whore and bend over for me whenever I want? Huh? Are you just a desperate anal craving ho who needs to be someone's bitch? Answer the question slut!"
"Yes!" Haley moaned through gritted teeth, "I love it! I love being fucked in the ass, I'm an ass slut, oh my God Rachel, make me your ass whore, mmmmmmm, make me the second biggest anal whore in Tree Hill, oooooooooooooh Gaaaaawwwwwwddddddd, fuck me! Fuck me! Fuck me, fuck my ass, mmmmmmmm ohhhhhhhhh, fuck my ass and make me your bitch, ooooooooohhhhhhhhhhh fuckkkkkkkkkkk, I'll be all those things and more if you just fuck me and make me cum!"
After she and Brooke laughed at Haley's response Rachel decided that her BFF deserved a reward so she suggested, "Hey Brooke, since your precious tutor girl decided it was ok to let go of her ass why don't you take over spreading them for me? Get yourself a real good look at my cock sliding in and out of this whore's ass, mmmmmmmmm, your precious tutor girl now nothing but an anal whore for me, ohhhhhhhhhhh, the two of you nothing but my little bitches, does that sound good to you bitch?"
"Hell yeah." Brooke replied eagerly, having already done what she was told.
Not needing to be told twice Brooke had eagerly kneeled behind Haley and had taken over spreading the other girl's butt cheeks and was now giving Rachel and herself the best view possible of Haley's little butt hole stretching for that strap-on cock. Which was awesome. Sure, Brooke mourned the loss of getting to see the pleasure on Haley's face and watching from afar as one girl anally pumped another, but the close-up looked at the penetration more than made up for it. Oh yes, Brooke loved watching that big dick pumping in and out of Tutor Girl's butt hole. She always did, but this was extra special. Although she occasionally looked up to see the look on Rachel's face.
It was rarely that worth it, Rachel either gleefully leering at Haley's dildo stuffed shit hole or staring directly at Brooke, in the case of the latter the two rivals becoming lost in wickedly smiling at each other as the redhead continued dishing out a slow but steady sodomy to the third member of their all girl threesome. Once or twice Brooke even lent her head up so she could kiss Rachel, two of them making out passionately while Haley continued to get butt fucked like the little bitch she had become. And more importantly in this moment, Rachel Gatina's little anal bitch! Oh yes, that's what Tutor Girl had become, the thought of it putting a wide smile on Brooke's face
"Hey Brooke..." Rachel asked with a grin on her face, "You wanna taste Tutor Girl's ass?"
"Hell yeah I do." Brooke replied eagerly.
"Well then, open your mouth, and say aaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhh." Rachel demanded.
"Aaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhh." Brooke did as she was told.
Joyfully opening her mouth as wide as she could Brooke watched as Rachel slowly pulled her strap-on out of Haley's butt and then slid it into the oh so tempting target Brooke was providing. At first Brooke didn't even close her mouth, instead of just allowing Rachel slid all the way to the back of her mouth and then give her a gentle face fucking, the brunette's eyelids fluttering as she tasted Haley's rectum on her tongue. Then Brooke finally closed her mouth around that yummy toy and moaning loudly and happily, before starting to suck on it again. Which she did gently at first but with ever-increasing suction until she was sucking on that butt flavoured strap-on for all she was worth.
Rachel just watched this with obvious enjoyment, Brooke knowing this because she spent most of her time looking up into the redhead's grinning face as she gave her the best blow job possible. Of course to make it the best blow job possible Brooke simply had to lower her mouth down further onto the dick, Rachel helping out in a big way by grabbing the back of her head and thrusting harder into her mouth, between the two girls forcing that long hard object down Brooke's throat at least halfway to her stomach. It wasn't long before her nose was touching Rachel's crotch and she was deep throating the entire length, and more importantly getting the last few drops of Haley's anal cream off that hunk of rubber.
For a few moments Rachel just watched with glee as Brooke choked and gagged around her fake cock, then she started to fuck that pretty mouth again, thrusting harder and harder until she was roughly face fucking her rival. As in her thighs were literally smacking against that cover girl face with so much force Rachel wouldn't be surprised if she 'accidentally' broke Brooke's nose or at least bruised that beautiful face. And while Rachel certainly wasn't trying to do that the most sadistic part of herself thought it would be hot to mutilate Brooke in such a way. Especially if her frienemy had to see a plastic surgeon or something, to fix the damage she was doing to that pretty face.
Honestly though it was good enough just to use her mouth as a cunt, or a slutty ass hole. Oh yes, Rachel gritting her teeth as she fought back whatever mercy she might have for her friend and just used her mouth like a whore's loose little cunt. She took out months of frustration, of being called names, but being constantly put down by this pretty brunette only for Rachel to be now well and truly showing Brooke who was the superior female. And Haley too. Oh hell yeah, she, Rachel Gatina was putting Brooke Davis and Haley James Scott in their places. Making them both her little fuck holes, she was using for her pleasure. And it felt so, so good doing it.
Especially as, of course, she just had to read that in other ways, "Ooooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhhhhh, take it bitch! Take it take it take it! Ohhhhhhhhhhhhh fuckkkkkkkkkkkkk, take it all down your whore throat, like the slut you are! Yessssssssssssss, suck it, mmmmmmmmmm, and get every drop of your bestie's butt cream! Ah fuck yeah, mmmmmmmmmmm shit!"
As much fun as it was to fuck Brooke's face Rachel found herself spending so long doing that Haley's butt hole completely closed, which was unacceptable. So without warning Rachel switched holes, pulling out of Brooke and giving her friend a chance to catch her breath while anally penetrating the girl she had never really liked, the redhead grinning wickedly as she heard Haley's squeals of pain and pleasure as her anal passage was once again skewered on that strap-on. Then, once every inch was back inside Haley's butt, Rachel restarted the sodomy, this time only butt fucking her new bitch for a few minutes before pulling out and stuffing her dildo back inside Brooke's mouth.
Rachel repeated this over, and over, and over again, feeding Brooke a ridiculous amount of her friend's ass and for the captain of their squad to passionately suck one cheerleader's cock clean of another cheerleader's anal cream. And Brooks enthusiasm for this perverted act only increasing. In fact the only one who seemed not to enjoy this constant switching was Haley. The annoying girl's whines of frustration become increasingly loud and obnoxious until she clearly couldn't take it anymore. Which of course, was exactly what Rachel wanted, and she grinned wickedly while this little bitch begged to get her cute little butt fucked.
"Please..." Haley whimpered.
"Yes?" Rachel pushed.
"Fuck me." Haley whined.
"Well, since you asked so nicely." Rachel grinned.
Haley cried out joyfully as Rachel plunged that big dildo back into her butt. The fact that the annoying redhead had been sodomising her for over an hour by now meant there was no pain whatsoever as she was once again anally penetrated. In fact her loosened back passage now felt like a perfect fit for the cock which has stretched around so painfully at the beginning, Haley feeling nothing but pure pleasure as Rachel began pumping her pooper. Soon enough Haley was glad that she wasn't spreading her ass cheeks anymore because Rachel continued to pick up that pace until her hips were crashing into her cheeks, hard enough to make them jiggle with the impact and make Haley feel like she was being spanked.
It would probably be worth worse if she was still spreading her cheeks, although Haley had to admit the twinge of pain of having Rachel's thighs roughly smack into her ass was barely noticeable thanks to incredible pleasure echoing throughout her body, pushing her closer and closer to orgasm by the second. It was this type of pleasure, and the pleasure she was about to receive, which made the overwhelming humiliation all worth it, Haley promising herself in the moment she would tell Rachel whatever she wanted to hear so long as she could cum. In fact for this type of pleasure she would mean every word, Haley silently apologising to her husband because no matter how much she loved Nathan her love for him couldn't compare to her need to be roughly ass fucked to orgasm by other women.
"Harder! Fuck me harder! Oh please Rachel, make me cum!" Haley begged when she finally got desperate enough, "Pound my slutty little butt hole, and make me cum like the whore I am! Oooooooooooooh yesssssssssssssss, make me your whore, if you can. Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh, make me like Brooke. Make me your bitch! Ah fuck, I'll be your bitch, if you just make me cum! Ooooooooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh Gooooooooooooooooodddddddddddddddddddd yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssssssssss, mmmmmmmmmmmm, make me cum make me cum make me cum, AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK!"
Squealing with delight Haley came and came hard, her cum literally squirting out of her cunt with the force of a hose and seemingly never end. Naturally her mind melted and she became a puddle of happy goo, completely unaware of what was going on other than the climaxes rocking her body from sheer heaven that was being butt fucked into submission by another woman. One thing that the now sex crazed Haley James Scott did was lift herself up onto all fours and begin slamming her ass back against Rachel, who was clearly taken aback for a moment but quickly recovered and kept up the ass fucking at a hard and rough pace until she came herself, at which point she became just as lost as Haley, both as Brooke's friends becoming completely lost in the anal sex. oh fuck, it was so fucking hot.
Captivated by the sight Brooke hammered two fingers in and out of her own pussy while using one of her other hands to reach round and play with her ass hole while Rachel thoroughly wrecked Haley's rectum, at various times calling out encouragement even though she was sure her friends couldn;t hear her. They certainly didn't respond, the only change from the extremist being Haley collapsing so she was face down, ass up again with Rachel pounding in and out of her ass hole. Then finally the particularly hard orgasm forced Rachel to stop, the redhead looking like she was going to for sure collapse only to lock eyes with Brooke and give her an evil grin.
"So, Tutor Girl, who's my bitch?" Rachel asked with a wicked chuckle.
"Brooke?" Haley sassed, although her voice was weak, and it took a few long seconds to even utter that word.
"Yes." Rachel greeted with an evil laugh, before quickly adding, "But so are you, and you know it. Ooooooooooh yessssssssss, I just proved it, by making you cum like a bitch, with my dick in your ass. Oh yeah I did, ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhhhh, and now? You're going to further prove it by spreading those cheeks of yours, and join Brooke in showing me my handiwork."
As she spoke, Rachel slowly began pulling her cock out of Haley's ass, causing her to cry out and whimper pathetically in the process. Unsurprisingly, that was the only reply she really had for her, for at least a full minute, as one cheerleader slowly pulled her cock from another's butt. Especially because Rachel was spreading those cheeks, giving herself the best possible look at this obscene act. Sadly she didn't have enough strength to lift herself up to do this, instead relying on simply rolling into her side, taking Haley with her in the process. But oh God, was really satisfying. Especially when it came all the way out, leaving a gaping crater behind.
For a few long seconds, Rachel just stared with disbelief, and then remembered that Haley was supposed to be the one here spreading her cheeks, therefore she was setting a bad example. So, extremely reluctantly, one cheerleader let go of the other, the redhead shuffling back a bit, so she could get the best look possible at the brunette's butt. And more importantly, that gaping butt hole, which could actually be seen pretty clearly without having those cheeks spread, a sign that this bitch really had taken one hell of an anal pounding. Although that didn't mean she didn't appreciate it when her new bitch did as she was told. In fact, it was exactly the opposite, Rachel chuckling wickedly, and happily providing Haley with more encouragement.
"Oooooooooooh yesssssssssssss, that's it, Tutor Girl. Show me that gaped butt hole." Rachel eagerly taunted with a chuckle, "Ohhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhh, show me the butt I just fucked, like your husband never could. And far more important to you, better than Brooke ever could. Better than Peyton, for that matter. Mmmmmmmmm fuck yeah, I own that ass now, and you know it."
"No." Haley whimpered softly.
"Yes." Rachel grinned, "And you're proving it by spreading those cheeks for me. Oh yeah you are, oooooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhh, and now? You're gonna suck my cock. Ohhhhhhhhhhhhh yesssssssssssss, further prove that you're mine, by sucking my cock clean. Come on, mmmmmmmmm, I want you to give me a better blow job than you ever gave your husband."
There was another brief pause, then Haley just whimpered pathetically, and just did as she was told. Which honestly, made Rachel disappointed. Part of the fun of topping Haley was her defiance. Oh well, hopefully when she wasn't emotionally exhausted, this bitch would try and fail to fight back. But whatever the case, Rachel got one hell of a show right now. Namely, Haley James Scott wrapping her lips around the dildo which had just pummelled the deepest part of her bowels. And the best part, was upon tasting that perverted flavour, Haley James Scott actually moaned in pleasure. Just like Brooke Davis, before her. Making Rachel Gatina grinned once again.
As she gently cupped the brunette hair in front of her, encouraging Haley to suck her cock even more enthusiastically, something which unsurprisingly very much worked, Rachel's mind wandered to all of the fun that she would have with these two sluts. And maybe even, all three of them. Oh yes, all she needed now was Peyton, and Rachel would have the full set. First though, she was going to have to make sure that Haley and especially Brooke were thoroughly broken in. Which meant a lot more butt fuckings, among other things. Which was just the way that she liked it. The way she wanted it. After all, who thought it would be so much fun tutoring Tutor Girl?
- 6
- 7
- 8
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

Tutoring Tutor Girl