Adult-FanFiction.org : Television / Streaming

The miracle in the mistake
By : Nadine21
Category: G through L > Glee
Views: 2576 -:- Recommendations : 0 -:- Currently Reading : 0
Disclaimer: I don't own Glee and make no money of this story
Chapter List
- 1
- 2
Title: The miracle in the mistake
Pairing: Puck/Kurt
Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or anything else you may recognize
Beta: RoseWalton
Summary: What if Kurt and Puck in a relationship before Quinn got pregnant. How will Kurt react when he finds out that the baby was Puck's and what will happen between them?
Rating: Not sure yet but it will probably end as a NC 17
Author notes: I know I changed the timeline and how the events played out but I had to be creative in order for the story to play out how it should. This is fanfiction so get over it.

Prologue
"What do you mean Finn isn't the father?" Asked Kurt confused and a little scared. "Quinn said it was his."
Mercedes couldn't believe she was the first to get a hold on such information. If there was one thing that was known about Mercedes Jones, it was that she was a notorious gossiper, why anyone would tell her something was beyond her; although Puck forgot that bit of information, and she was the first to know about it.
"Puck just told me he was the father." Kurt stopped dead; he couldn't believe what he was hearing. He looked around and saw they had attracted some attention from the surrounding students in the corridor. Even though Kurt felt dreadful, this was not the place to discuss this.
"Come on," Kurt and lead her to his car, as soon as the doors closed behind them he turned to Mercedes
"Who did you tell?"
"Only the guys in Glee, expect Quinn, Finn and Rachel, you know how she is, she would immediately tell Finn." Mercedes answered rolling her eyes.
"You do realize that this is a Glee matter only and you are not to tell anyone else?"
"I know and I told the others the same."
"Good." Kurt said while looking around the parking lot. In the corner of his eye, he saw someone in a letterman jacket. What he saw made his insides freeze. There he was, his Noah, the guy he feel hopelessly in love that summer and who he thought loved him as well. He was standing with Quinn discussing something with her, that was all the proof he needed but there was more, the expression on his face was one he had when he was with Kurt, an expression of love. He closed his eyes not wanting to cry or think about it. He turned to Mercedes and with a forced smile asked if she needed a ride home. At her nod he turned the ignition, just in time, seeing as Noah was headed his way.
As soon as he got home he buried himself under the covers. Today should've been a great day but what Mercedes told him threw it of the tracks. Half an hour later his phone rang a couple times, he knew who it was although he was too scared to answer.
Suddenly the door to his basement flung open and an irritated Latino Cheerio entered his personal space.
"Barbie, what are you doing under the covers? I just got your message; shouldn't you be packing for New York?" Santana asked, sternly.
The other guys in Glee, expect Puck, didn't know that she, Brittany and Kurt were best friends since they were about five years old. Santana called him 'Barbie' since he changed his clothes as often as a kid changed a Barbie doll. If he was ever asked who his best friend was he would answer, that it was Santana and Brittany and not Mercedes, this was a big surprise to a lot of people.
"Mercedes told me!" Santana gave him a cold hard look. She had hoped Kurt wouldn't find out, until Puck himself plucked up the courage to tell him to his face.
"Bitch!" Kurt smiled a little, but then remembered why he was lying in his bed hiding.
"I thought he loved me, I should've guessed it would be too good to be true."
"Honey, you don't even know what happened."
"I should have guessed something was wrong. He's been distracted the last couple weeks. I thought it was because of the fight. Last Friday night he said he couldn't come to our Friday evening movie, and then I found out from Mercedes today that he was babysitting with Quinn, trying to convince her that he was the right guy for her and not Finn. How could I be this naive, I thought we would at least last until college… I understand that he is scared of loosing the baby but how can he promise her a relationship if he loves me?"
"I don't know, honey, I wish I could give you the answers you are looking for but I can't. But what fight Barbie?"
"Remember about three months ago, I was at your place crying and you beat some sense in my head,"
"Is that the one of the times you had the fight about, announcing your relationship?"
"Yes, I think that was one of the last times I believed he loved me. He tried so hard to convince me that it would be okay if we came out together, but I was just so scared what would happen to him if we came out as a couple. I mean everyone knew I was gay even before I came out, but Noah, he's a football player, he has a reputation as the fucking town slut, more than that though, he is one of the guys, they would have killed him. I don't think he's loved me for over three months… Fuck, why hasn't he broken up with me yet?"
Santana's gaze was on the floor, she had the feeling that he wasn't talking to her, but rather analyzing his relationship with Puck. She let him rant for a while but she finally had enough.
"That's enough, I think you should talk about that with Puck, not me, but first you need some time to reflect. This is why it's great that you're going to New York for a week, now get packing." Kurt nodded, wiped his face free from the tears and got packing.
A little while into the packing his phone started to ring for at least the tenth time that afternoon. Kurt threw a panicked look at it, but before he even thought about answering it Santana had it in her hands and moved to the other room. As soon as she answered the phone a panicked voice came through the receiver.
"Princess, thank god are you alright? I am trying to get hold of you the entire afternoon, why did you leave without waiting for me?"
"Puck its Santana, Kurt is in the bathroom right now."
"Oh, hey Santana. Is everything alright, Kurt hasn't been answering his phone and didn't wait for me after school like he usually does…"
"I guess he was about to call you, but you know how he is when he has something on his mind." Santana said while trying hard not to yell at Puck at what he has done to her best friend, but she knew she couldn't, this was something that Kurt had to do himself.
"Alright, could you please ask him if it would be alright for me to come over?"
"Puck, Kurt is packing right now, he isn't going to be home tonight and his flight is leaving in a few hours"
"Flight, what flight? Where is he going?"
"You know he sent his papers and portfolio to that school he is always talking about in New York? Well they sent an acceptance letter, but they want to talk to him first. He's got an appointment for tomorrow afternoon."
"They accepted him already, but he is only a junior, he still got a year and a half left of high school?"
"I know which is why this is a great honor. He only has to keep his grades the same as they were until now and as soon as he finishes high school he can leave for NY. Isn't that great?" Santana was so full of pride for her best friend.
"Yeah that is great." Puck immediately answered in a cheerful tone, but Santana could tell it was faked. She smirked 'let that bastard rot for all that I care, he doesn't deserve Kurt, he doesn't deserve anyone really. Apart from Quinn and their 'to be' lizard baby.'
"Would you please just tell him that I called and wish him good luck." Santana reluctantly agreed and Puck mumbled a thank you and a quick goodbye before hanging up
After calling the airport for Kurt, she went to see if he was ready to leave.

They were rehearsing, Rachel and Finn were late which was unusual but nobody paid any attention to it. I was bored and frustrated. Not only was Quinn ignoring me, but my boyfriend was in NY for the week and wasn't answering his phone. I would never admit it to anyone but I was fucking terrified. I loved Kurt, I was sure of it the moment I woke up next to Quinn naked and hung-over. I knew I should've told Kurt as soon as I saw him and if not then at least when I found out Quinn was pregnant. I couldn't tell him though, I was terrified that Kurt would leave me, I still am. I never really told Kurt that I loved him at least not in so many words, but I'm almost positive he knows I can only hope that he'll still believe it even when he does find out, but one could never be too sure.
I had no idea what to make of the whole baby gate situation, I wanted everyone to know that the baby was mine that way I could be there for it, I could be a proper father. Something I never had. But if everyone found out, Kurt would eventually hear, I loved Kurt, but I really didn't want him hearing this from a third party. Every time I spend with Kurt all I can feel is guilt, if he knew what I've done to him, he would never forgive me, but if Quinn was willing to keep the baby, then know matter how much I loved him, I would still have to leave him.

The door to the choir room flung open and Finn came with his fists raised. Before Puck could react Finn was beating him. Puck immediately knew that Finn had found out.
It was Schuester that separated them. Everyone could only watch in horror as Finn tried again to attack Puck. Santana looked around and saw Rachel's guilty look. 'Great, that is why we didn't tell her, she would have told Finn if only to get him to be with her. Not that I mind, this way when Kurt comes back tonight he can confront his cheating son of a bitch boyfriend.'
"What do you think you are doing?" Schuster asked while still trying to contain Finn.
"They are lying to me, both of them are lying. Tell me the truth, tell me!" Finn was screaming unable to contain his feelings of betrayal and anger. He was looking directly at Quinn for when he said the last sentence.
Quinn was crying, how had he found out? It would have been much easier if he still believed he was the father, but now the cat was out of the bag and she had to tell the truth. She didn't like Puck, not only because he got her pregnant but because she had the feeling as if he was trying this hard to get her was only for the baby's sake and not because he liked her. She admits she dated Finn in hopes to get closer to Puck and no one was happier than her when they slept together. The next morning Puck told her that it was a mistake and there would be no repeats, her world came crashing down. Now she hated him and if giving up the baby was going to hurt him, well someone said that revenge was sweet. By denying the baby was his she was hurting him that's why it hurt to admit it to Finn.
"Yes, Puck is the father."
"Everything was a lie, the whole hut tub thing was only made up?" at her nod he looked up and saw the faces of his fellow Glee members. He saw no surprise in their eyes only pity. That did it for him.
"You all knew?" looking at their guilty looks he had enough. "I am done. I am done with all of you."
After Finn left with Quinn and Rachel following him Puck turned to look at his fellow Glee members.
Puck looked around the choir room and saw Santana and Brittany's accusing looks, Artie his best friend, just shrugged and nodded towards Mercedes. Puck sighed. He should have known better than telling something like that to the gossip queen of McKinley High.
"Who else did you tell?" Puck asked frantically. You could see the fear in his eyes. What if Kurt knew and if he did why hasn't he confronted him?
"Well everyone who's here," Mercedes answered not even looking from her phone. Puck immediately felt relieved until Santana piped up…
"Kurt as well, right Mercedes?"
"Huh, oh yes of course. I told everyone in Glee well expect Finn, Rachel and Quinn." Shit, Puck just felt the weight of the world on his shoulders for the first time, and it hurt like a motherfucker.

I am posting this story here but you can find it on ff.net as well only here it will be with all the content. You can find it under my pen name alaison.
- 1
- 2
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

The miracle in the mistake	By : Nadine21 Category: G through L > Glee Views: 2576 -:- Recommendations : 0 -:- Currently Reading : 0
Disclaimer: I don't own Glee and make no money of this story

The miracle in the mistake