The Deepest Love

BY : Lubysrock
Category: G through L > Gilmore Girls
Dragon prints: 5038
Disclaimer: I do not own The Gilmore Girls, nor any of the characters from it. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.

Title: The Deepest Love

Author: LubysRock

Rating: NC-17

Summary: Luke and Lorelai spend a night together even though she is
engaged to Max. Luke however, doesn’t know that she is engaged. What follows
is a crisis for everyone close to Luke and Lorelai, and the couple themselves.

Disclaimer: I don’t own anyone you recognise here. The song “Let’s
Make Love” belongs to Faith Hill and Tim McGraw

Lorelai dragged herself into the diner and let out a sigh.

“Good evening to you too,” Luke said, pouring her a coffee.

“Bless you,” she replied.

“So what’s got you so down?” Luke asked.

Lorelai shrugged. “I don’t know. Rory is on camp and Max is busy grading
end of term papers. I’m just lonely I guess.”

Luke smiled. “Hey, want to finish our poker game?”

Lorelai’s eyes lit up. “Really?”

Luke nodded. “I’m going to close in about an hour and then we can start.”

Lorelai rubbed her hands together. “Excellent. I’m going to kick your

Luke grinned and shook his head. “You wish.”


An hour later the game had begun in earnest. Luke had locked the door
and closed the curtains, not wanting to be prosecuted for gambling. Each
had a beer and were sitting comfortably in Luke’s apartment. Lorelai on
the couch and him on a cushion on the floor.

“Two,” Lorelai demanded, placing two cards down.

Luke groaned. “Come on, Lorelai. Be reasonable. How many cards have
you been given in the past five minutes?”

Lorelai frowned and poked her tongue out at him. “Don’t be mean, Luke.
This just a friendly game of poker. I mean, we’re not even playing for

Luke chuckled. “Yeah, I know. It’s not even strip poker either. Then
the stakes would really be high.”

Lorelai grinned. “Hey, have you ever played strip poker?”

“Once or twice. What about you?”

“Once with Christopher. I never figured you as a guy for strip poker.”

Luke frowned. “Why not?”

Lorelai shrugged. “I don’t know. You just seem…”

“What?” Luke asked.

“Not the strip poker type,” Lorelai supplied. “Hey, want to play truth
or dare?”

“We’re playing poker!” Luke told her.

“Not anymore,” Lorelai said, putting her cards down. “Truth or dare?”

“I didn’t say I was playing,” Luke answered.

“Do you want me to be sad and pouting again?” Lorelai asked him.

“Truth,” Luke grumbled.

Lorelai grinned. “Excellent. How many times have you been in love?”

“Do I have to answer this?”

“Hey, at least you didn’t answer dare. That could have turned out nasty.”

“Fine,” Luke said. “Twice.”

“Who with?” Lorelai asked.

“Hah!” Luke said, pointing a finger at her. “You can’t ask me that.
It’s my turn now.”

Lorelai frowned. “Fine. Go ahead.”

Luke smiled and stred oud out on the floor, as Lorelai’s eyes followed
him intently. God, he could get lost in those eyes. He shook his head.
“Truth or dare?”

Lorelai pondered this for a moment. Either way, whatever she said,
this whole situation could be very dangerous. She sighed. “Truth.”

“Okay. How many times have you been in love?”

“As far as I know, once.”

“What do you mean as far as you know? How can you not know?” Luke said,
giving her a strange look.

Lorelai frowned at him. “Hey, I answered. And that’s three questions.
It’s my turn now.”

Luke crossed his arms. “Fine.”

“Truth or dare?”


“What’s the wildest thing you’ve ever done?”

“Mooned at Taylor.”

Lorelai widened her eyes at Luke. “No way!”

Luke nodded. “Yep. When I was ten.”

Lorelai fell about laughing. “That is just so un-Luke like!”

Luke frowned slightly. “Truth or dare?”


“Who was your first love?”

Lorelai smiled. “That’s easy. Patrick Swayze when I was seven.”

Luke rolled his eyes.

“Truth or dare,” Lorelai asked him.

Luke pondered his choice. Then he grinned. So she thought he was inhibited.
This would show her. “Dare.”

Lorelai’s eyes widened. She couldn’t believe what he had just said.
Never had she expected the word dare to come out of Luke’s mouth, especially
in this context. She stared at him as he lay on the floor, hands under
his head, a large grin on his face. Damn him. He was teasing her! “Are
you sure?” she asked, putting her hands on her hips.

He stalled for a minute. She knew what he was up to and he was tempted
to change his mind for a moment. Then he thought what kind of teasing he
could get after that. “I’m sure.”

Lorelai smirked at him. She could have some fun with this. Now, what
did she want Luke to do most in the world? Something that she knew he’d
never do. The perfect idea popped into her mind. “Alright. I dare you to
kiss me.”

The self-assured grin disappeared from Luke’s face as his eyes widened.
Out of all the dares he could think of Lorelai suggesting, that one had
certainly not been on the list. “Kiss you?” he choked out.

“Surely you’re not chicken?” Lai sai said, raising an eyebrow. She
wasn’t worried. There was no way Luke was going to kiss her, no matter
how close he got.

Luke stood up, his legs a little wobbly. He took a deep breath and
sat next to her. “Are you sure?”

Lorelai was starting to worry now. Surely he wasn’t… “I’m sure,” she
said stubbornly. There was no way she was going to let Luke know that she
was nervous.

He nodded and rested one of his hands on her face. Lorelai’s eyes fluttered
shut as his lips started inching towards hers. Finally, his lips barely
touched hers in the smallest of kisses. With just the barest of touches,
the electricity level in the room soared about a thousand feet. She loved
the feeling of his lips against hers and she gasped in surprise as he deepened
the kiss. Lorelai surprised herself as she opened her mouth to his foraging
tongue and as their tongues met and entwined, she let out a low guttural
moan of pleasure. Luke smiled at hearing her moan of pleasure and then
let out his own moan as Lorelai shuffled down on the couch and moved him
above her.


Baby I've been drifting away. Dreaming all day

of holding you, and touching you.

Only thing I wanna do is be with you,

as close to you as I can be.


He gave in as he pressed his body against hers, his hard lines melding
with her soft curves. Luke moved his lips down to her neck and alternated
licking and sucking as she murmured in pleasure.

“Lorelai,” he said, moving away slightly.

“Mmm?” she answered, her eyes a dark coal colour.

“Are you sure about this? Because once we start, I don’t think I’ll
be able to stop. And I don’t have anything with me so…”

“I’m on the pill. And I’m sure.” Lorelai murmured as she urged his
lips down to meet hers again.

Luke let his hands slip up underneath her shirt and he pulled her closer
towards him, brushing her chest up against his. Impatient, Lorelai tugged
his flannel shirt off, and then took off his undershirt. She leaned up
and kissed him gently as her fingers lightly circled upon his chest. Luke
let out a growl and removed her top and bra, exposing her breasts to him.
She looked up at him with a look of shyness and he soon alleviated that
feeling as he bent down to kiss them.

“Luke,” she moaned, running her hands through his hair.


Let's make love all night long,

until all our strength is gone.

Hold on tight, just let go,

I wanna feel you in my soul,

until the sun comes up.

Let's make love.


He smiled and gathered her closer, kissing her lips deeply. Lorelai
ran her fingers lightly down his chest and stilled when she reached the
buckle of his jeans. Luke flashed her a smile and helped her trembling
fingers undo the buckle. After removing his jeans and boxers, he helped
her slide out of her jeans and panties and they went over to the bed. Hovering
above her, Luke took in her body and smiled at the blush on her face. He
bent down and kissed her gently as she arched her body up to brush against
his. He let out a moan as het het her softness brush up against his hardness.

“Oh God, Luke,” she murmured as he suckled her breast and she let her
fingers wander across his back, urging him on. Luke let his hands wander
around her body as he alternately kissed and sucked her breasts and Lorelai
felt a surge of desire as he ran his fingers around her inner thighs.


Do you know what you do to me?

Everything inside of me

is wanting you, and needing you.

I'm so in love with you.

Look in my eyes, let's get lost tonight

in each other.


She pulled him back up to meet her lips and they kissed a long, deep
kiss, tongues entwining, passion escalating. He pulled her closer to him
and she whimpered as her over-sensitised breasts brushed against his chest.

“Luke,” she murmured, aching to feel him inside her.

In one fluid stroke he was there, filling her completely. Both let
out a cry of pleasure at the union and he kissed her gently on the lips.

“You’re beautiful,” he told her.

Lorelai blushed slightly and nudged him with her hips. He kissed her
again, letting the pleasurable feel of their joining last longer and then
began to move within her.

Luke was wrestling with his emotions, and then finally leant down to
her ear. “I love you,” he whispered.

Lorelai knew that that declaration was not something that Luke would
tell her in the heat of passion, no matter how heated the room had become.
Her eyes widened but she soon changed her tune, as she could feel the start
of her orgasm. He held himself back, wanting to give her pleasure first.
He watched her eyes, watching them squeeze shut as she drew closer and
closer to the edge.


Let's make love all night long,

until all our strength is gone.

Hold on tight, just let go,

I wanna feel you in my soul,

until the sun comes up.

Let's make love.


“Open your eyes,” he told her softly.

Lorelai’s eyes, darkened with pleasure opened and focussed on the man
looking at her. Pleasure was coursing through her body. “Oh my God,” she
cried, as her focus was lost, and she climaxed, arching her back off the
bed. Luke thrust harder into her until his own orgasm followed, and he
filled her with his warmth, her muscles clenching around him.

Extreme pleasure ran throughout both of them for a few minutes as they
came back down to earth. With a slow passionate kiss, Luke eased her onto
his shoulder and they snuggled together, falling asleep.


They made love three more times that night, each time taking their
pleasure to greater heights.

In the early hours of the morning, Luke rolled over to a small sniffling

“Lorelai?” he asked, placing a hand on her shoulder.

“Go back to sleep, Luke,” she told him.

He rolled her over to face him and gently wiped the tears away with
the pad of her thumb. “Lorelai, what’s the matter? Why are you crying?”

“It’s nothing,” she answered. “Just go back to sleep.”

“Please tell me what the matter is,” Luke said, worry etched throughout
his face.

“I’m fine,” Lorelai answered. She forced a smile. “Trust me.”

Luke nodded, his face still grave. He rolled onto his back and placed
an arm around her as he drifted back to sleep.


Lorelai stared at the clock and watched it turn to 6am. She knew by
Luke’s even breaths that he was asleep and she gingerly got out of the
bed, careful not to wake him. Gathering her clothes she quietly dressed.
Lorelai turned and looked at the man fast asleep in the bed and she wiped
a tear from her eye.



You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story